Does A 401 Loan Or Withdrawal Make More Sense
When you consider the potential tax consequences associated with an early withdrawal, a 401 loan may seem more attractive. Of course, there’s one drawback with both options: you’re diminishing your retirement savings.
With a 401 loan, you’d have the ability to replace that money over time. If you’re cashing out an old 401, however, there’s no way to put that money back. In both cases, you’re missing out on the power of compound interest to grow your retirement wealth over time.
One upside of deciding to borrow from a 401 for a housewhether you take a loan or make a withdrawalis that it may allow you to avoid paying private mortgage insurance if you offer the lender a large enough down payment. Private mortgage insurance protects the lender, and it’s typically required if you’re putting less than 20% down on a conventional mortgage. Private mortgage insurance can be eliminated when you reach 20% equity in the home, but it can add to the cost of homeownership in the early years of your mortgage.
Traditional 401 Penalty Exceptions
A traditional 401 provides a tax deduction on contributions, and taxes withdrawals as ordinary income. Normally, early withdrawals are subject to a 10 percent penalty tax, but exceptions are available. Early withdrawals escape the penalty if they result from job separation after age 55, rollover into another retirement account, death, total disability, financial hardship, medical bills exceeding 7.5 percent of your adjusted gross income or substantially equal regular payments based on your life expectancy. Even if you meet one of these exceptions, it’s important to keep in mind that if you withdraw money from your traditional 401 to purchase a home or for any other reason, that money will still be taxed as income.
Benefits Of Investing In Real Estate Through An Ira
The benefits of investing in real estate through an IRA are similar to the benefits of investing in stocks or mutual funds through an IRA. The tax advantages can help you keep more of your property’s rental income and shelter you from capital gains tax if you sell a property you own.
Consider this simplified example. Let’s say you buy an investment property for $200,000, and you generate $1,500 in monthly rental income after expenses. Not only would this rental income be tax-free as long as it remains in the IRA, but no matter how much you sell the property for, you wouldn’t have to pay capital gains tax to the IRS. If your self-directed IRA is of the tax-deferred variety, you won’t have to pay a penny of tax until you withdraw money from the account, and if it happens to be a Roth account, your income could be tax-free — forever.
Read Also: How To Pull Out Of 401k
Find The Mortgage Option Thats Right For You
Your 401 account may seem tempting as an untapped source of cash, especially if youre struggling to come up with the money for a down payment on your new home. While this is a viable option, and there are ways to mitigate the penalties, it should only be used as a last resort. Consider applying for a low down-payment loan like an FHA or VA loan, or, if you have one, making a withdrawal from your IRA.
Whatever you decide, make sure you consult with a mortgage specialist before committing to an option. Rocket Mortgage® has experts waiting to help you navigate the tricky waters of home loans. If youre ready to take that next step toward a mortgage, then get started with our experts today.
Take the first step toward the right mortgage.
Apply online for expert recommendations with real interest rates and payments.
Should You Use Your 401 To Buy A House
There are good reasons for not using your 401 to buy a house. Even if youre comfortable with the 10% early withdrawal penalty, you will still be incurring long-term consequences by reducing your savings. That, in turn, will damage your future growth potential.
Taking out $10,000 from a $20,000 401 account, for instance, leaves you with only $10,000 that will continue accruing interest. With a 7% annualized rate of return, that $10,000 could become $54,000 over 25 years compared to $108,000 had you not withdrawn $10,000.
Withdrawing from your 401 account is essentially taking out a loan against yourself. If you want to pay it back, you also need to pay interest, and the time spent paying it back is time that could have been spent on growth.
Also Check: How Much Should I Put In 401k
Can I Take Out A 401 Loan To Buy A House
While not all 401 plans allow you to take out a loan from your account, a good many do. Vanguard reported that in 2018, 78% of its 401 plans allowed participants to borrow from their retirement accounts.
Check with your plan sponsor to see whats allowed. If your retirement plan allows you to take a loan from your 401, you may be able to use that money for a home down payment or closing costs.
One important distinction to note: You cant borrow money from an IRA.
Here are some things to consider before you take out a 401 home loan.
Better Real Estate Agents At A Better Rate
Enter your zip code to see if Clever has a partner agent in your area.
If you don’t love your Clever partner agent, you can request to meet with another, or shake hands and go a different direction. We offer this because we’re confident you’re going to love working with a Clever Partner Agent.
Contact Us
Read Also: Can I Set Up My Own 401k Plan
Which Option Should You Choose
The option that is best for you depends on what your goals are and which downsides you are willing to deal with, as both options have downsides.
The biggest downside of 401 loans is that they have to be paid back. The biggest downside of 401 withdrawals is that you will take a massive tax hit. If your top priority is to prevent losing a lot of money, then you should consider going with the 401 loan.
However, if your top priority is to not have to pay back any money that you take out, then you should go with the 401 withdrawal.
Regardless of which option you take, your 401 will still take a big hit, at least temporarily. Removing any money invested in a tax-deferred retirement plan will prevent you from earning the compound interest that you gain if you leave the money in your 401.
How To Use 401k To Buy A House
If you dont have the entire amount or youre short on cash for a down payment, you might be wondering if you can use 401k to buy house if your dream home comes on the market. The answer to your question is yes, youre allowed to use funds from your 401k for a home purchase.
However, there is an opportunity cost in doing so the funds you take from your 401K retirement account cannot be replenished as quickly as you may imagine. You can start thinking about using retirement funds to buy a house, either by taking a loan or withdrawing money from the account. Keep in mind that not all providers allow the option of a 401k loan for down payment. If they dont allow a 401k loan or if you need more than what is allowed, you will be obligated to go with an outright 401k withdrawal for a home purchase.
Don’t Miss: What Is A 401k Vs Roth Ira
How To Buy Your Dream Vacation Home With Your Ira
Summer vacations are the perfect time to find a vacation home in an ideal location. Investors are often in the market for clever solutions for affordability, so its important for them to be aware of their available investment tools. One such tool is the self-directed IRA.
Did you know that your IRA, 401, or Health Savings Account funds can be used to buy real estate? Lets look at some of the options available for purchasing a second home with IRA funds.
Ready to open a new self-directed IRA? Complete our simple online new account application to open an account in a matter of minutes!
Look At Current And Future Finances Now
If you are thinking about buying a second home, then the first step is to take inventory of your current and future finances. Be sure to determine the in order to evaluate how much you can afford. Are you planning on using the second home as a rental during part of the year? If so, then dont count on that rental income as part of your income. After all, you never know if you are going to have a period without a renter. After undertaking this assessment, you will then have a better sense of what you really can afford.
Also Check: Where Should I Put My 401k Money
Borrowing From Your 401k
Another option with a 401k is to take out a loan. Your loan can be up to $50,000 or half the value of the account, whichever is less. As long as you can handle the payments , this is usually a less expensive option than a straight withdrawal. Though you will pay interest, you wont pay taxes or penalties on the loan amount.
A few things to know about 401k loans:
- Since youre incurring debt and will need to make monthly payments on the loan, your ability to get a mortgage may be affected.
- The interest rate on 401k loans is generally about two points above the prime rate. The interest you pay, however, isnt paid to the company it goes into your 401k account.
- Many plans give you only five years to repay the loan. In other words, if you borrow a large amount, the payments could be substantial.
- If you leave your company, you may be required to pay back the outstanding balance within 60 to 90 days or be forced to take it as a hardship withdrawal. This means youll be hit with taxes and penalties on the amount you still owe.
- If payments are deducted from your paycheck, the principal payments will not be taxed but the interest payments will. Since youll be taxed again on withdrawals during retirement, the interest payments will end up being double-taxed.
Be Careful Using 401 For A Down Payment
The biggest challenge most buyers face when purchasing a home? Coming up with that big down payment. Even if your mortgage lender only requires a down payment of 5 percent, that still comes out to $10,000 for a modestly priced home of $200,000. Many buyers simply don’t have that much cash lying around.
If you have a 401 plan at work, though, you might have a convenient source for down payment funds. You are allowed to borrow money from this retirement account for a down payment. You just have to pay back your loan — with interest — on time to avoid any penalties or taxes.
But does doing this make financial sense? That depends upon how badly you want the home, how close you are to retirement and how certain you are that you can pay back the loan on time.
Heather McRae, senior loan officer with Chicago Financial Services in Chicago, said that a 401 loan has helped several of her clients gather the funds they need for down payments. She considers it a smart financial move for borrowers who know they can handle the payback schedule.
“If you don’t have the money for a down payment and you don’t have family members who are kind enough to gift you the down payment, you’re kind of out of luck,” McRae said. “The 401 loan is often the best option for these buyers. If you haven’t saved the money for a down payment and you’ve fallen in love with a property, the 401 can make the purchase work.”
Recommended Reading: Where Do You Get A 401k
What Is A 401k
A 401k is an employer-sponsored retirement plan that many, but not all, companies establish for their employees and often contribute some amount too. Upon enrollment in the plan, you can choose how much youd like to contribute either a set dollar amount or a percentage of your salary. That amount is then deducted from your paycheck and goes into your 401k investment plan on a pre-tax basis. As of 2019, people can invest up to $19,000 in their 401k each year.
Each plan has its own limited list of available investment options for you to choose from. If you do not select a specific plan, you will be auto-enrolled into a default investment selected by your plan provider.
The big thing to understand about a 401k is that you will be taxed upon withdrawing money from your account in retirement. It doesnt matter if the funds you withdraw came from your own contribution or the earnings from your investment in either case, the funds will be considered part of your gross income on your tax return and taxed accordingly.
Q: When Would You Recommend Not Using A 401k Loan To Finance Home Remodeling Or Repairs
DistilledDollar: If you plan on leaving your employer soon, then taking out a 401k loan will not help you. Once you are either terminated from your employer or leave voluntarily, you must repay the remaining balance of the loan within 30 to 60 days, depending on your employer.
Another scenario where I would not recommend a 401k loan is if you are nearing the age of 59 1/2. The amount of time you have to repay your loan is diminished. If you take out a 401k loan and are unable to repay by 59 1/2, then you will need to pay regular income taxes in addition to the 10% early withdrawal penalty.
Don’t Miss: Where To Move Your 401k Money
Buying A Home Is A Big Financial Investment And Even If You Dont Have The Cash To Purchase A Home Outright Youll Probably Still Need Money On Hand For A Down Payment
If you havent saved for a down payment, though, you might be considering other ways to get access to the money you need now, including your 401. Thats because some 401 plans let you borrow money from your retirement savings and pay it back over time.
But even if you arent planning to retire any time soon, taking a loan from your 401 can come with big drawbacks, like missing out on potential investment growth. So before you dip into your nest egg, consider if its really the best option for you.
Low And No Down Payment Mortgages
Instead of getting a loan for your down payment, you can look into some of the government-backed loans that offer low and no down payment mortgages.
FHA Loans FHA home loans require a low 3.5% down payment, making them a prevalent option. With a down payment this low, you may not need to use your retirement account to afford the down payment.
VA Loans If youre a Veteran, you could qualify for a VA home loan with no down payment. This is one of the greatest benefits offered to Vets in our Country. Not only do VA loans provide 100% financing, but no mortgage insurance is required.
USDA Loans The U.S. Department of Agriculture guarantees USDA loans for low-to-median income families in the countrys rural areas. TDA finances 100% of the purchase price for eligible borrowers.
Conventional 97 Loan This type of conventional loan was created by Fannie Mae to compete with the low down payment government-backed loans. As the name suggests, a conventional 97 loan offers a 3% down payment, allowing you to finance 97% of the purchase price.
Home Possible / HomeReady Loans Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac created the Home Possible and HomeReady loan programs for first-time homebuyers who meet the income limits, have a 620 credit score and a 3% down payment. Your income must be below 100% of the area median income to be eligible.
You May Like: Can I Borrow From My Solo 401k
Investing In Rental Properties
One interesting way to use a 401 is to purchase rental property. That is, the 401 can own the property and receive rental income tax-deferred. The 401 custodian must allow for real estate transactions. For example, self-employed individuals can use a self-directed Solo 401 to buy income property. If you buy a second home this way, you cannot live in it nor provide any services to manage or maintain the property. You, your family and certain other individuals are disqualified from occupying the home, becoming tenants in the home, or otherwise receiving any personal benefit from it. The 401 can own a mortgage on the property, as long as the mortgage is collateralized only by property and doesnt make the account owner personally liable for the loan.
References
Pros And Cons Of Borrowing From Your 401k
|
Pros |
|
|
|
When Using Your 401K to Buy a House is a Good Idea
While most financial advisors will strongly advise you not to use your retirement funds for your down payment on a house, there are certain situations where it could save you a lot of money.
Avoiding PMI with a 20% down payment
Lets say youre buying a $300,000 home with a $30,000 down payment with a 5% rate for 30 years. You will be required to carry private mortgage insurance because youre putting less than 20% down. Your monthly payment will be $1,449.42, including insurance, property taxes, and PMI of $112.50 monthly.
If you can borrow another $30,000 from your 401k account, you will have a $60,000 down payment, 20% of the purchase price. You avoid PMI and have a monthly mortgage payment of $1,288.37, a savings of $161.05 per month over 30 years, saving you $57,978 over the life of the loan.
Becoming a First-Time Homeowner
Buying a home is cheaper than renting in the long run. Not only can you save money each month, but you will also be building equity with each payment.
If you can Pay Back to Loan in Less than a Year
Read Also: Can You Take Out Your 401k To Buy A House
