Why Is A 401k A Bad Idea
Theres more than a few reasons that I think 401s are a bad idea, including that you give up control of your money, have extremely limited investment options, cant access your funds until your 59.5 or older, are not paid income distributions on your investments, and dont benefit from them during the most expensive
Recommended Reading: How Much Do You Need In 401k To Retire
Do You Qualify For A Hardship Distribution
If your plan allows it, you might qualify for a hardship distribution. But doing so isnt easy. First, you must prove what the IRS considers immediate and heavy financial need. In general, the IRS defines this as:
- Medical expenses for you, your spouse, or dependents
- Costs directly related to the purchase of your principal residence
- Postsecondary tuition and related educational fees, including room and board for you, your spouse, or dependents
- Payments necessary to prevent you from being foreclosed on or evicted from your principal residence
- Funeral expenses
- Certain expenses relating to the repair of damage to your principal residence
The amount of the distribution is limited to your own contributions to the plan and possibly your employers contributions but doesnt include earnings or income on your savings. It cant be for more than the amount of the specific needand you cant have other resources available to cover it. Plus, youll have to pay both income taxes and a 10 percent penalty on the distribution.
What Are Some Alternatives To A 401 Loan
When cash is tight, borrowing from your 401 plan and paying yourself interest may seem like a good idea. But before you borrow, weigh all your options. Here are a few.
Recommended Reading: How Do You Find Your Old 401k
Vacation On Your 401 It Could Cost You
Its time! Months, maybe years, of planning have led to this moment: the family is going on vacation. Its also in this moment where our bankers may hear the question Should I borrow from my 401 to pay for the trip?
First youll have to determine if your 401 plan allows for a loan. Not all companies permit employees taking loans from their plan. But if it does, be sure to get all of the facts about the loan program before using it.
You should consider the effect on your retirement savings:
Its easy to request the loan from the plan. You dont need a credit check. Most plans require you to keep 50 percent of your vested balance in the plan for collateral.
The interest rate and fees are comparable to those you would incur from other lending institutions.
You pay yourself back. The interest paid back to the plan goes to your account. Thats the upside of taking a loan, so lets consider the downside:
If youre using your money at a lower interest rate, you could cost yourself lost earnings on the account. Maybe your account would have earned more if it stayed invested in the market.
If you reduce your regular 401 contribution because you now have a loan payment, youre missing out on building your retirement account.
The loan fees are deducted from your account, which reduces your overall retirement savings balance.
Wisdom is best when shared.
If you benefitted from this info, a friend or family member may, too.Thought this was helpful? Give it a share.
How Is 401k Loan Interest Paid
You’ll have to pay the money back with interest. The good news is, the interest is credited to your 401k account, not to your employer, so you are paying the money back to yourself. Paying the loan back comes right out of your paycheck too. So keep in mind this will lower your take home pay until the loan is paid back.
Recommended Reading: How Much Can I Loan From My 401k
Q: Does It Make Sense To Borrow From My 401 If I Need Cash
When cash is tight, your 401 can seem like a perfectly reasonable way to make life a little easier. The money is there and its yoursso why not tap it to pay off debt or get out of some other financial jam? Or you might be tempted to use it to pay for that dream vacation you deserve to take.
Stop right there. The cash in your 401 may be calling youbut so is your financial future. The real question here: Will taking the money today jeopardize your financial security tomorrow?
Im not saying a 401 loan is always a bad idea. Sometimes, it may be your best option for handling a current cash need or an emergency. Interest rates are generally low and paperwork is minimal. But a 401 loan is just thata loan. And it needs to be paid back with interest. Yes, youre paying the interest to yourself, but you still have to come up with the money. Whats worse is that you pay yourself back with after-tax dollars that will be taxed again when you eventually withdraw the moneythats double taxation!
Who Should Withdraw From Their 401 Early
Just because you qualify for a hardship-related withdrawal doesnt mean you should take one without weighing all your other options.
The experts we spoke with were all in agreement that withdrawing from your 401 shouldnt be your first move. However, they also indicated that if youre truly in need, then you should take advantage of the CARES Acts allowances.
It should be a last resort option. People shouldnt get carried away and start using their 401 assets just because they can, Pfau says.
Also Check: Can You Use Money From 401k To Buy A House
Don’t Miss: How Much Do I Need To Put In My 401k
Hardship Withdrawal Vs 401 Loan: An Overview
Is it ever OK to borrow from your 401 plan, either as a 401 loan or a hardship withdrawal? After all, your plan is a powerful retirement savings tool and should be carefully handled. Indeed, data from Fidelity shows that the average account balance has climbed to $112,300, as of February 2020.
The recently enacted CARES Act lets you make a penalty-free COVID-19 related withdrawal or take out a loan from your 401 in 2020 with special repayment provisions and tax treatment.
The primary advantage of saving in a 401 is the ability to enjoy tax-deferred growth on your investments. When youre setting aside cash for the long term, a hands-off approach is usually best. Nevertheless, there are some scenarios in which taking money out of your 401 can make sense.
Before you pull the trigger, though, its important to understand the financial implications of tapping your retirement plan early. There are two basic avenues for taking some money out before reaching retirement age.
Can I Withdraw From My 401k If I Have An Outstanding Loan
Most 401 plans allow participants to tap into their retirement savings. Find out if you can withdraw from your 401k if you have an unpaid 401 loan.
When contributing to a 401 plan, most people have every intention of accumulating a sufficient retirement nest egg that they can live off in retirement. However, when heavy financial emergencies occur and you do not have an emergency fund, you could be forced to raid your retirement savings to settle the urgent financial needs.
Most 401 plans allow you to take a 401 loan against your retirement savings, or a hardship withdrawal if you are below 59 ½. However, there are circumstances when you can withdraw from your 401 if you have an unpaid loan. For example, if you leave your job or are fired, you could rollover your 401 to an IRA or the new employerâs 401 even if you have an outstanding 401 loan. When this happens, the outstanding 401 balance will not be rolled over, and you will have until the tax due date to pay off the loan balance.
You May Like: How To Find Out If You Have Unclaimed 401k Money
Considering A Loan From Your 401 Plan
Your 401 plan may allow you to borrow from your account balance. However, you should consider a few things before taking a loan from your 401.
If you dont repay the loan, including interest, according to the loans terms, any unpaid amounts become a plan distribution to you. Your plan may even require you to repay the loan in full if you leave your job.
Generally, you have to include any previously untaxed amount of the distribution in your gross income in the year in which the distribution occurs. You may also have to pay an additional 10% tax on the amount of the taxable distribution, unless you:
- are at least age 59 ½, or
- qualify for another exception.
If You Lose Your Job You May Have To Repay The Money By Tax Day Next Year
Leaving your job used to trigger a requirement that you repay your loan within 60 days. However, the rules changed in 2018 under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. Now you have until tax day for the year you took the withdrawal to pay what you owe.
So, if you borrow in 2021, you will need to repay the full balance by April 15, 2022, or by Oct. 17, 2022, if you apply for an extension. If you borrow in 2022, you’ll have to repay the full balance by April 17, 2023, because April 15 of that year falls on a Saturday, or by Oct. 16, 2022, since the 15th of October falls on a Sunday.
This longer deadline does slightly reduce the risks of borrowing. But, if you take out a loan now, spend the money, and then are faced with an unexpected job loss, it could be hard to repay your loan in full.
You May Like: How To Access Your 401k Early
Consider All Options Before Borrowing A 401 Loan
If youre considering taking out a 401 loan, you should make sure you understand all the fees, rules and terms of the agreement before you apply. You should also consider all other options, since there are definite risks to borrowing from your 401 and digging into your retirement savings. Once youve decided on the path thats right for you, be sure to come up with a budget and savings plan to help you avoid needing to borrow in the future.
Is There Any Way To Take An Early 401 Distribution Penalty
There are a few situations in which a penalty-free early distribution is allowed:
- You become disabled.
- You die and a payment is made to your beneficiary or estate.
- You pay for medical expenses exceeding 7.5 percent of your adjusted gross income.
- The distributions were required by a divorce decree or separation agreement .
As you can see, the IRS doesnt make it easy to take your 401 money early under any circumstances!
| Pluses |
|---|
Recommended Reading: Can You Convert A Roth 401k To A Roth Ira
The Cares Act And 401 Loans
The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act, which became law on March 27, 2020, enables people who had taken out a 401 loan to delay for up to one year payments owed from that date through December 31, 2020. Interest would still accrue on your outstanding balance during the period of delayed payments.
The CARES Act also eliminated the 10% federal tax penalty on early withdrawals made from your 401 through the end of 2020.
The CARES Act enabled employers to increase the amount of a loan that employees could take against their 401 to $100,000 or the entire vested portion of their account, whichever was lower. However, that ability expired on September 22, 2020, and the maximum loan amount returned to $50,000 or 50% of the available amount, whichever is less.
To be eligible for any of the provisions of the CARES Act, you, your spouse, or your dependent must have been diagnosed with the coronavirus or its associated disease using a test approved by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. You also must have experienced financial hardship for one of the following reasons:
- You were quarantined, furloughed, or laid off, or your work hours were reduced due to the coronavirus pandemic.
- You were unable to work because of a lack of child care due to the coronavirus pandemic.
- You closed or reduced the hours of a business you owned or operated due to the coronavirus pandemic.
How Does A Cares Act 401k Withdrawal Work
Plan participants should speak to their plan administrator to ask about the process for requesting a 401k or IRA withdrawal. The participant may need to complete a withdrawal form and provide documentation to substantiate the nature of their hardship.
The request will need to be approved by either a committee or a designated person responsible for making hardship-withdrawal decisions. If the participant qualifies for a hardship withdrawal based on IRS regulations, the plan administrator will process the request. Depending on the plan administrator, approving and processing the hardship request can take several weeks. For that reason, a hardship withdrawal may not be a great option for the most time-sensitive financial needs.
If the participant doesnt qualify for the distribution, the administrator will deny the request and notify the participant.
Prior to the CARES Act, plans would automatically withhold 20% of early withdrawals for tax purposes. The CARES Act eliminated the 20% automatic withholding on 401k withdrawals. However, participants may want to avoid spending the full amount withdrawn in order to have funds available to cover the tax bill later.
Dont Miss: How To Calculate Rate Of Return On 401k
Don’t Miss: How Do You Get Money From 401k
Review Options Carefully And Get Help
Facing a temporary money crunch is not uncommon. But if it happens to you, think carefully about your options before turning to your 401. And if you do decide that you must tap into this account, learn everything you can about how it will affect your retirement planning and tax situation. Talk with your financial advisor and a tax professional about it so you can be better prepared to make the right choices.
If You’re Thinking About Borrowing From Your 401 Consider The Pros And Cons First
- Borrowing against your 401 is generally frowned upon, but in some circumstances, it can make sense.
- When you take out a loan from your 401, you don’t have to fill out a lengthy application, the interest rate is typically lower than it is for a personal loan or business loan, and there aren’t any penalties.
- A big downside of borrowing against your 401 is that it harms your retirement saving potential. During the repayment period, you are barred from contributing to your 401.
- This article is for business owners and professionals who are thinking about borrowing money from their 401 retirement fund.
Ask most financial advisors about borrowing from your 401, and their response will be brief and blunt: “Don’t do it.”
Those three words mostly sum up the prevailing sentiment on the subject. Still, there are some situations in which borrowing from your 401 might make sense. If you’re considering taking out a loan against your plan, know the pros and cons first.
Editor’s note: Looking for an employee retirement plan for your business? Fill out the below questionnaire to have our vendor partners contact you about your needs.
You May Like: Can You Move An Ira To A 401k
What Are The Disadvantages Of Withdrawing Money From Your 401 In Cases Of Hardship
- Taking a hardship withdrawal will reduce the size of your retirement nest egg, and the funds you withdraw will no longer grow tax deferred.
- Hardship withdrawals are generally subject to federal income tax. A 10 percent federal penalty tax may also apply if you’re under age 59½. contributions, only the portion of the withdrawal representing earnings will be subject to tax and penalties.)
- You may not be able to contribute to your 401 plan for six months following a hardship distribution.
Repayment Terms On 401 Loans
- You must pay back your loan within five years. You can do so via automatic payroll deductions, the same way you fund your 401 in the first place. There is no penalty for paying off the loan sooner than that.
- You must pay interest on the loan, at a rate specified by your 401 fund administrator. Typically the rate is calculated by adding one or two percentage points to the current prime interest rate.
Also Check: How To Open A 401k With Fidelity
