Leave The Money Or Move It
One thing you can do is leave your retirement savings in your former employer’s plan, if it’s permitted. Of course, you can no longer contribute to the plan or receive any employer contribution.
However, while this might be the easiest immediate choice if it’s available, it could lead to more work in the future.
Basically, finding old 401 accounts can be tricky if you lose track of them. There is, incidentally, pending legislation in Congress that would create a “lost and found” database to make locating lost accounts easier.
If you can avoid it, you don’t want to cash out your 401.Kathryn HauerCertified financial planner with Wilson David Investment Advisors
“It’s really common,” Tolitsky said. “People switch to a new job, they have life changes going on, they forget about it and then 10 years later they aren’t even sure who was with or who the provider was.”
Also be aware that if your balance is low enough, the plan might not let you remain in it even if you want to. If the balance is less than $1,000, your plan can cash you out which can lead to a tax bill and a penalty.
“If you can avoid it, you don’t want to cash out your 401,” said Kathryn Hauer, a CFP with Wilson David Investment Advisors in Aiken, South Carolina. “Doing so with a traditional 401 means you’ll probably pay a 10% tax penalty.”
However, the Roth money grows tax-free and is untaxed when you make qualified withdrawals down the road.
Pro #: You May Gain Flexibility
Your new employers plan may have different investment options, loan options, protections against potential creditors, or other benefits that better suit your needs than your former employers plan. If you continue working until and beyond 72 years of age, you may be excused from required minimum distributions if your new employers plan allows it.
Think Again If You Are Thinking About Cashing Out Your Old 401k
With all of the above, you may be thinking it would be easiest to simply cash out your 401k and then start over. However, this is not true. If you cash out a 401K before you are 59.5 years old, you will be faced with a 10% penalty.
Although there are some exceptions, they tend to be grim things such as medical needs, disability, and death. And that does not count the state and federal taxes you will be required to pay. Ultimately, you may lose as much as 40% of your money.
Even if your money is reinvested right away, during the process you will lose so much that it will take many years to recover.
Also Check: What Does Rollover Mean In 401k
What Should I Do With My Old 401
Doing a flip on skis is scary, completing a 401 rollover should not be.
The days of starting a job out of college and working at one company until you retire with a Golden Rolex are long behind us. More likely, you will work for a variety of companies over your career, you may even manage a few side hustles, or own your own businesses along the way. This will often lead to a trail of old 401 retirement accounts, which you probably have no idea what to do with. Dont feel bad you are not alone.
As a Certified Financial Planner, I am constantly asked by people about 401 rollovers, and how to consolidate old retirement accounts. People want to know what will be best for their own financial situation. Before you make a move and transfer your old accounts, you should first understand your options to help make the best choice for your financial future. A fiduciary financial planner can help guide you through this process if you get stuck.
What is a 401 Rollover?
You may be wondering what the heck is a 401 rollover, anyway? Keep reading as we walk you through what you need to know.
When you change employers or enter retirement, you likely have four choices of what to do with your retirement account. Most of these steps will be the same whether you have a 401, Profit Sharing Plan, Cash Balance Pension Plan, 403, or 457 retirement accounts.
Choice 1: Leave the money where it is, in your former employers 401 Plan.
Which road will lead to a secure retirement?
Option : Roll It Into An Ira
If your new employer doesnt offer a 401 or you dont like their option, you can roll your 401 into an IRA.
Rolling over accounts is easier than it sounds. You may need to open an IRA at a brokerage company and sign a few papers that allow the brokerage to transfer the money into your new account. This option will help keep your balance growing tax deferred and you can continue to make tax-deferred contributions.
Don’t Miss: What To Do With 401k When You Quit
What Should I Do With A 401 From My Old Job
Weighing the pros and cons will help you choose the best option.
Question: I’ve switched jobs a few times and I have an old 401 that Im not sure what to do with. Should I roll it over? Is it OK to just let it sit there?
Answer: In most cases, it makes the most sense to roll your money over into an IRA or into your new 401 plan, if that’s allowed. may or may not be allowable–the specific bylaws vary by plan, so check on that first.)
That said, there are some good reasons to consider leaving your assets within the confines of a former employer’s plan.
Here are some considerations to help you weigh the pros and cons of both decisions.
Roll It Over Reason #1: You can do better on costs in your new plan, or on your own. Do some due diligence on your new plan and your old plan. plans.)
Often, 401 plans charge administrative fees, and many times the participants themselves bear these costs. Other times, plans use high-cost share classes of mutual funds that have extra fees embedded inside of them. Those extra fees tend to be more prevalent in plans of smaller employers, because small 401 plans have fewer investor dollars.
Larger plans can charge lower fees because they have scale advantages. With your assets pooled with other plan participants’, your new employer’s plan may have access to institutional share classes of funds, which typically feature very low costs and may be unavailable to investors with smaller balances.
Taking The Cash Distribution May Cost You
Avoiding cash distributions can save you from taxes and penalties, because any amount you fail to roll over will be treated as a taxable distribution. As a result, it would also be subject to the 10% penalty if you are under age 59 1/2.
Since the taxable portion of a distribution will be added to any other taxable income you have during the year, you could move into a higher tax bracket.
Using the previous example, if a single taxpayer with $50,000 of taxable income were to decide not to roll over any portion of the $100,000 distribution, they would report $150,000 of taxable income for the year. That would put them in a higher tax bracket. They also would have to report $10,000 in additional penalty tax, if they were under the age of 59 1/2.
Only use cash distributions as a last resort. That means extreme cases of financial hardship. These hardships may include facing foreclosure, eviction, or repossession. If you have to go this route, only take out funds needed to cover the hardship, plus any taxes and penalties you will owe.
The CARES Act, enacted on March 27, 2020, provided some relief for those who need to make withdrawals from a retirement plan. It lifted penalties for withdrawals made through December 2020 and provides three years to pay back any early withdrawals.
Also Check: How To Access My 401k From Previous Employer
You May Be Able To Leave Your Account With Your Former Employer At Least Temporarily
Changing jobs is stressful, even in the best of circumstances. If youve lost a job and are scrambling for re-employment, youre likely focused on that. But eventually you will need to figure out what to do with your 401.
If your balance is $5,000 or more, you can leave the money right where it is which will give you time to decide the best course of action for you.
What you should do right away, regardless of the 401 balance in your old plan, and as early as your first day at the new job, is to sign up for your new companys 401 plan. Even if your new employer has an automatic opt-in feature that does not kick in for one to three months and if you rely on that, rather than taking the initiative you can miss 30 to 90 days of contributions and matching funds, Bogosian advises.
After six months, youve got a handle on the job, know youre going to stay and have some experience with your new plan. Youre now in a better position to compare your last 401 plan with this new one, including the diversity of the investments and the costs.
But what happens if the balance in your old 401 is less than $5,000? Your former employer may force you out of the plan by placing your funds in an IRA in your name or cashing you out and sending you a check.
Some companies have recently adopted auto portability meaning your small balance may automatically transfer to your new employers plan. Check with your HR Department or plan sponsor to see if this applies.
Call Your Old Employer
If you suspect you have missing 401 funds or even if you’re not sure, it’s still a good idea to contact old employers and ask them to check if they’re holding your old account. Your former company will have records of you actually participating in a 401 plan.
You’ll either need to provide or confirm your Social Security number and the dates of your employment, but if you can, you’ll have found the fastest way to dig up a missing 401.
Read Also: How To Rollover Old 401k To New 401k
Roll It Over Into Your New Employer’s Plan
You’ll have to double check with your new employer to make sure they accept rollovers from a previous job. But if you get the go ahead to do this, you’d be able to just manage one 401 account rather than two different accounts potentially from two different plan providers .
“Some people find that having just one 401 account makes it easier to see all their money in one place,” MacDonald explained.
The money will still have the chance to grow in your new employer’s plan just make sure you like the new investment options available to you. And you’ll be able to save on all the additional costs that come with just keeping your balance with your old employer.
And unlike with the IRA rollover option, you won’t have to take required minimum distributions at age 72 if you move the money into your new employer’s 401 plan.
“Ultimately, it comes down to convenience,” MacDonald said. “And if you like seeing all of your assets in one place then this option could make sense.”
What Are The Tax Implications Of Cashing Out Your 401
Withdrawals from pre-tax 401s are taxed as ordinary income in other words, theyre taxed at your highest marginal tax rate. Note that this is the same rate at which your job or freelance income is taxed.
Ordinary income tax is higher than long-term capital gains tax, which is the tax charged on any realized stock gains after youve held the stock for a year or longer in a taxable account.
If you have a Roth 401, you wont pay ordinary income tax when you withdraw money, as you already paid tax on this money when you made contributions to the account. You will still be liable for the 10% early withdrawal penalty, however, if youre below 59 ½.
Don’t Miss: How Do You Take A Loan Out Of Your 401k
When Changing Jobs Is This Your Best Option
When an employee leaves a job due to retirement or termination, the question about whether to roll over a 401 or other employer-sponsored plan quickly follows. A 401 plan can be left with the original plan sponsor, rolled over into a traditional or Roth IRA, distributed as a lump-sum cash payment, or transferred to the new employers 401 plan.
Each option for an old 401 has advantages and disadvantages, and there is not a single selection that works best for all employees. However, if an employee is considering the option of transferring an old 401 plan into a new employer’s 401, certain steps are necessary.
Rolling Into An Ira Stay On Top Of The Move
If you decide to roll over your 401 into an IRA not sponsored by your new employer, your IRA sponsor or advisor will help guide you through the process to ensure the money gets to the proper destination in a timely manner.
Be sure your new broker/advisor has experience with rollovers, especially if you have company stock in your 401. Why? Because company stock is liquidated when its rolled into an IRA, and later, when distributed, may be taxed as ordinary income resulting in a higher tax liability.
As recommended above, stay vigilant until your money is safely in its new home and that you have proof typically verified online through the IRA providers website.
Also Check: How Soon Can I Get My 401k After I Quit
You May Like: How Much Money Do I Have In My 401k
Start Making Qualified Distributions
If you meet the age requirement, you can begin making qualified distributions from your former employers 401k plan. While you wont be assessed a 10% penalty on these distributions, you will have to pay income taxes at your current ordinary income tax rate if the distributions are made from a traditional 401k.
The Takeaway On Finding Lost 401 Money
If you suspect that you’ve left a 401 behind somewhere and don’t attempt to locate it, you’re risking losing the plan — and the money — for good.
But if you don’t respond, a company holding an old 401 account has no obligation to pursue the issue further, and eventually will relinquish your old account to the state, and all of the funds held, as well.
Don’t let that happen to you. Use the tips listed above to make every effort to find your lost 401 account and get the money back for yourself, and don’t let “free” retirement slip out of your control.
Also Check: Does Having A 401k Help You Get A Mortgage
Cashing Out A 401 After Leaving A Job
The IRS established the 401 as a tax-advantaged plan for employees, rather than the self-employed. This works fine most of the time, but in an era when people change jobs far more often than they used to it also has created some confusion. What do you do with this account, thats supposed to grow over decades, when you change employers? There are a few common options. A financial advisor can offer you valuable insight and guidance on handling tax-advantaged accounts.
Rollover To New Employer
A better alternative to leaving your 401 behind is to rollover the old 401 to the new employerâs 401 plan. This option allows you to combine your retirement savings so that you have better control over your 401 assets. You can ask the plan administrator of the old 401 account to transfer the 401 balance directly into the new employerâs plan. You can also ask the plan administrator to send you the check, which you must deposit in the new employerâs 401 in 60 days.
If the new employer allows 401 loans, you have a bigger asset base against which to borrow. You can borrow up to 50% of your 401 assets. The highest amount you can borrow from a 401 is $50,000.
You May Like: How To Start A 401k For Employees
There Are Several Situations In Which This Could Happen
Eric is currently a duly licensed Independent Insurance Broker licensed in Life, Health, Property, and Casualty insurance. He has worked more than 13 years in both public and private accounting jobs and more than four years licensed as an insurance producer. His background in tax accounting has served as a solid base supporting his current book of business.
Our Take: Start Planning Now
If you have an old 401k plan or are about to leave a job where you contributed to a 401k, give some thought now to how you will handle the money in your account. A rollover IRA is the best option for most people, but a financial advisor can help you determine whats right for your specific situation.
The content contained in this blog post is intended for general informational purposes only and is not meant to constitute legal, tax, accounting or investment advice. You should consult a qualified legal or tax professional regarding your specific situation. Keep in mind that investing involves risk. The value of your investment will fluctuate over time and you may gain or lose money.
Any reference to the advisory services refers to Personal Capital Advisors Corporation, a subsidiary of Personal Capital. Personal Capital Advisors Corporation is an investment adviser registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission . Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training nor does it imply endorsement by the SEC.
Don’t Miss: What Are The Advantages Of A 401k