Why You May Not Want To Roll Over Your 401
Rollovers arent for everyone. Consider the following:
You Need Money Access to Your Money Earlier
If you retire early, you can start making withdrawals from your 401 account penalty-free starting at age 55. Under most circumstances, you may not begin making withdrawals from an IRA until age 59 ½.
You Have a Large Number of Assets You Need to Protect
401 assets are protected in the event that you need to declare bankruptcy or you have creditors coming after you. IRA protection status varies by state, so you may not be covered.
If you live in California, Georgia, Maine, Mississippi, or West Virginia, your IRA has the potential to be seized if you are found to be at fault for a costly lawsuit. Even in states that protect IRAs, bankruptcy protection is typically limited to $1.28 million in assets.
You Want to Hold Onto Your Money a Little Longer Before Dipping In
401 accounts and IRAs both require that payouts start to be received no later than when the owner of the account turns 70 ½ years old. However, 401 accounts have a loophole that allows owners to defer these payments until after they actually retire IRAs offer no such loophole.
Why Would You Want To Roll Over A 401
Heres why you may consider a switch.
Most 401 accounts include management fees, though some employers will cover this fee. Since most IRAs are self-directed, they do not charge annual fees related to management.
Some IRA providers, like Vanguard, offer both free account maintenance and fund expense ratios significantly less than most 401 management accounts. You can even open an account managed by a robo-advisor and pay less than 0.50% in management fees.
Loopholes to Early Withdrawals
If you withdraw funds from your 401 before retirement , youll pay a whopping 10% in penalties.IRAs are much more flexible when it comes to early withdrawals.
For example, you can withdraw from your IRA to fund a first time home purchase or higher education expenses.
A Wider Range of Investment Control and Selection
When you contribute to your 401 account, your employer most likely gets to decide where that money will go. With an IRA, you are in control and there are unlimited possibilities with stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and ETFs.
Improved Estate Planning Options
After you die, your 401 account will be disbursed to your beneficiaries as a one lump-sum payment. IRAs provide increased flexibility when it comes to estate planning and payout schedules.
Benefits Without Penalties
You can enjoy all of these benefits with no initial start-up feeits free to rollover your 401 into an IRA with most providers.
What Are Your Choices For A Rollover
In general, once you leave a job you have three choices for how to deal with your employer-sponsored retirement plan:
- Leave it with your old employers 401 plan: This approach requires the least amount of work, but may require you to have a minimum amount if you plan to maintain the account there.
- Roll it over into your new employers 401 plan: This approach will require you to file some paperwork, but youll have all your 401 money in one place. This choice can make sense if you like your new employers plan.
- Roll it over into an IRA: This move will require you to file some paperwork, but then youll have the complete freedom to invest the money as you see fit. If you liked the investment options you held in a previous plan, you may still be able to access those via an IRA.
, thats another option for a rollover. But this option is not typical for most individuals.)
If you roll over your 401 into an IRA, youll also want to consider the kind of rollover you need.
- With a Roth 401, youll likely be more interested in a Roth IRA, so that you can maintain the substantial advantages of that plan.
- If you have a traditional 401, then youll probably opt for a traditional IRA.
Recommended Reading: Is It Better To Have A 401k Or Ira
Rollovers Of Retirement Plan And Ira Distributions
Information on this page may be affected by coronavirus relief for retirement plans and IRAs.
Most pre-retirement payments you receive from a retirement plan or IRA can be rolled over by depositing the payment in another retirement plan or IRA within 60 days. You can also have your financial institution or plan directly transfer the payment to another plan or IRA.
The Rollover Chart PDF summarizes allowable rollover transactions.
Understand The Rules Procedures And Tax Implications
The simplest and easiest way to transfer funds is through a direct transfer, also called a trustee-to-trustee transfer, according to Forbes. In this case, your current provider will wire your money directly to your new 401 or IRA administrator. If one or both parties dont allow direct transfers, youll have to do an indirect transfer, which is rarely the better of the two options.
With indirect transfers, your 401 provider will liquidate your account and send you a check minus 20%, which the IRS requires your employer to withhold which youll then deposit into your new account. You must deposit the check within 60 days or the IRS will treat it the same as an early cash-out and youll be hit with harsh penalties and taxes.
If you roll over your existing 401 into a new 401 or into a traditional IRA, you wont have to pay any taxes on the rollover amount, according to the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority , because those kinds of accounts are funded with pre-tax earnings. If you roll over a 401 to a Roth IRA, on the other hand, you will have to pay taxes on the funds that you convert.
What To Consider When Choosing A Broker
If youre planning to roll over your 401 into an IRA, youll likely be most concerned with a broker that can do the following things best. Most brokers do offer an IRA, but some popular ones do not, but the brokers below all offer IRAs. We also considered the following factors when selecting the top places for your 401 rollover.
- Price: Trading commissions for stocks and ETFs have fallen to $0 at most online brokers, and thats great for investors. But there are other costs, too, perhaps most notably account fees, such as fees for transferring out of your account.
- No-transaction-fee mutual funds: The brokers in the list below offer thousands of mutual funds without a transaction fee. If youre rolling over your 401 and you like the mutual funds you have already, these brokers may allow you to buy and sell the same one without a fee.
- Investing strategy: While a 401 may limit your investing options to a pre-selected group of mutual funds, an IRA gives you the ability to invest in almost anything trading in the market. So we considered how each broker might fit an investors needs.
How To Start A 401 Rollover
If you are working for a private company, chances are they have a pension plan. Pension plans come in many different names but the most common is a 401.
401s in the United States are great because they let you invest in your retirement and your employer will match your investment. For example, if you put your payroll on automatic deduction of one thousand dollars every month, your employer will match a certain amount of that one thousand dollars. This is a great benefit and can really help you when it comes time for you to retire.
The downside to 401 is that they are stuck with your employer. They do not remain open once you leave your employer. This is why the 401 roll-over was created. It is really an individual retirement account with the same tax advantages. What you will be doing is you will roll over that 401 onto a new account. That way, it does not get stuck with your prior job. Here are some tips on how to create a 401 roll-over account.
Recommendation:Why Consider a Self-Directed IRA to Rollover Your 401
Recommended Reading: Is It Better To Contribute To 401k Or Roth 401k
Reasons For And Against Rolling Over Your 401
Saving for retirement doesnt necessarily have to include a 401 rollover to an IRA. In many cases, youre able to keep your 401 account even if you no longer work for the employer. However, like all financial decisions, there are pros and cons to both sides.
One major reason that rolling over your 401 can be helpful is that IRA providers boast better investment selections. 401s often have minimal choices, with target-date funds being some of the most common. But if you want to diversify your assets across stocks, ETFs, bonds, options and more, a brokerage is the way to go. The same goes for robo-advisors, though those decisions are automatic instead.
Brokerages that offer IRAs may also give out bonuses to prospective clients who open an account. These can come in the form of cash bonuses or even extra features and membership tiers. Taking advantage of offers like this can give a little boost to your retirement savings.
But perhaps the most important reason to roll over your 401 funds into a single IRA is consolidation. After all, the fewer accounts you have to manage, the more likely youll do so successfully. It can also be a pain to watch over multiple 401s at a few employers at once.
On the contrary, you may be fully happy with your 401. Simply put, if youre comfortable with your 401 provider, fees and investments, you may feel completely unmotivated to make a change.
If You Have Company Stock
Some retirement savers hold company stock in their 401 alongside other investments. In that situation, if you roll over all those assets to an IRA, you lose the potential to get a more favorable tax treatment on any growth those shares had while in your 401.
It gets a bit confusing, but the idea is that if the company stock has unrealized gains, you transfer it to a brokerage account instead of rolling it over to the IRA along with your other 401 assets. Upon transferring, you are taxed on the cost basis .
However, when you then sell the shares from your brokerage account whether immediately or down the road any growth the stock experienced inside the 401 would be taxed at long-term capital gains rates . This could be less than the ordinary-income tax treatment you’d face if the stock went into a rollover IRA and then were withdrawn.
Here’s an example: If the cost basis of your company stock is $10,000 and the gains on it were $20,000, you would pay ordinary taxes on the $10,000 when you transfer the shares to a brokerage account.
The $20,000 in gains, however, would be taxed at long-term rates once the stock is sold. Any further growth from the point of transfer to sale would be taxed as either short- or long-term gains, depending on how long you held it before selling.
“It’s a complex transaction, and if done incorrectly, the strategy loses its tax advantage,” said CFP Melissa Brennan, a financial planner with ARS Private Wealth in Houston.
Decide Where To Open Your New Ira
When opening an IRA, most people will look towards a brokerage, and for obvious reasons. 401 accounts are notorious for their relatively limited investment selections. But by rolling your funds into an IRA at a brokerage, youll get to choose from a significantly larger pool of potential investments. In fact, many offer some combination of stocks, bonds, exchange-traded funds , mutual funds, options and more.
Managing your own retirement funds takes a lot of time and energy, but a financial advisor can do it for you. Many financial advisors specialize in retirement planning and investing, which is exactly the combination youll need. If you go this route, your advisor will manage your investments in an IRA according to your needs and current savings situation.
If you prefer an even more hands-off approach to investing, a robo-advisor could be a good option. When you open an IRA with a robo-advisor, an asset allocation profile will be created for you based on your age, risk tolerance and proximity to retirement. The robo-advisor will then invest and manage your assets for you according to this plan.
Regardless of which way you go, make sure you understand any account, investment or advisory fees you may incur. An overbearing fee structure can have an extremely negative effect on your portfolio, so keep an eye out for this.
Considering A 401 Rollover Consider Your Options First
If you decide a 401 rollover is right for you, we’re here to help. Call a Rollover Consultant at .
One great thing about a 401 retirement savings plan is that your assets are often portable when you leave a job. But what should you do with them? Rolling over your 401 to an IRA is one way to go, but you should consider your options before making a decision. There are several factors to consider based on your personal circumstances. The information provided here can help you decide.
Read Also: Can I Take Out My 401k To Buy A House
Choose The Type Of Ira Account You Wish To Rollover Your 401 Into
This process can be a little daunting because there are so many different types of IRA accounts to choose from. The most common are Roth and traditional IRAs.
It is an advantage to transfer your old 401k into another retirement plan of the same nature as a traditional IRA or Roth IRA or another Roth 401. This will help you avoid paying taxes on the distribution when you eventually withdraw the money.
Direct Rollover Vs Indirect Rollover: Whats The Difference
Okay, once you decide to roll money from one account to another, you have two options on how to do the transfer: a direct rollover or an indirect rollover. Spoiler alert: You always want to do the direct transfer. Heres why.
With a direct rollover, the money in one retirement accountan old 401 you had in a previous job, for exampleis transferred directly to another retirement account, like an IRA. That way, the owner of the account never touches it, and you wont have to pay any taxes or penalties on the money being transferred. Once its done, its done!
Indirect rollovers, on the other hand, are a bit more complicatedand needlessly risky. In an indirect rollover, instead of the money going straight into your new account, the cash goes to you first. Heres the problem with that: You have only 60 days to deposit the funds into a new retirement plan. If not, then youre going to get hit with withholding taxes and early withdrawal penalties.
Now you should see why the direct rollover is the only way to go. Theres just no reason to take a chance on an indirect rollover that leaves you open to heavy taxes and penalties. Thats just dumb with a capital D!
Don’t Miss: Should I Move My 401k When I Change Jobs
Traditional 401 Vs Roth 401
The traditional 401, named after the relevant section of the IRS code, has been around since 1978.
With this plan, any contributions you make to the 401 account will reduce your income taxes for that year and will be taxed when they are withdrawn.
Roth 401s, named after former senator William Roth of Delaware, were introduced in 2006.
Unlike a traditional 401, all contributions are made with after-tax dollars and the funds in the Roth 401 account accrue tax free.
Typically, employees can take advantage of both plans at the same time, which is recommended among financial advisors to maximize retirement savings.
Because of the way the contribution limits work, it is possible to invest different amounts into each account, even year-to-year, so long as the total contribution does not exceed the set limit.
Access More Investment Choices
In a 401 plan, youre limited to the investment choices picked by your employer, usually a selection of mutual funds. If you roll over your 401 to an IRA, you may be able to expand your investment choices to include a broader range of funds, exchange traded funds or even individual stocks and bonds. Youll get more control over your portfolio, especially if you use a self-directed IRA, which allows you to invest money into more unorthodox assets like real estate.
Also Check: How Much Can You Borrow From 401k
Why You Should Roll Over Your 401 Into An Ira As Soon As Possible
By Eva Sadej
Blueleafs position: Roll over your old 401 into an IRA as soon as possible. IRA fees are both more transparent and lower than 401 fees, you have a much wider range of investment options, and its much easier to monitor your investments in an IRA than in an old 401.
Setting up a 401 is a piece of cake. You check off a box on a form at your company, and instantly theres money taken out of every paycheck and deposited into a retirement account in your name. You can determine the amount you want to put away, and many companies even have a program where they match your contribution up to a certain percentage . Sounds great, right? You check a box, and youre on your way to a more comfortable retirement: the very definition of a set-it and forget-it system.
Theres a simple, and relatively painless, solution to this missing money issue. Roll your money over into an IRA either before you leave the company or shortly thereafter. Your IRA then becomes attached to you and you alone, not to your company or some other entity that you might not know how to contact. This way, you always know where your money is and who to contact in regards to your investment mix.