If Youre Planning To Fire Or Semi
Heres the concept. When you convert funds from a pre-tax IRA into a Roth IRA, you incur taxes. If your income that year is low enough, you will pay low or possibly no taxes. Then, since its in a Roth account now, that money will be tax-free for future growth and withdrawals.
You will have to wait 5 years after the conversion to withdraw the money, in order to use this 10% early withdrawal penalty exception and avoid additional taxes. In this period, youll want to live off of savings, non-retirement investments, or existing Roth IRA principal distributions.
So, if you convert 1 years worth of expenses from pre-tax IRA to Roth IRA every year, then by year 6 you can start distributions and live off of your converted Roth IRA funds. This is why its called the conversion ladder you would need to do the conversions each year for a year in the future.
Plan this carefully, factoring in tax brackets and your other income for the year. This approach can work really well for FIRE followers once they retire, since they may have very low income for the year if theyre just living off of investments.
Contact Your Plan Administrator
When you have selected your course of action, contact your 401 trustee and ask for the appropriate paperwork. Whether you are taking a full withdrawal, requesting a loan or initiating a rollover, you will have to provide information on where you want the money to go, and in the case of a distribution, if you want any taxes withheld.
Be aware that if you take a 401 loan and leave your employer for any reason, the entire balance is generally due within 60 to 90 days, or else the entire outstanding loan balance will be considered a taxable distribution.
How To Avoid The Early Withdrawal Penalty
There are a few exceptions to the age 59½ minimum. The IRS offers penalty-free withdrawals under special circumstances related to death, disability, medical expenses, child support, spousal support and military active duty, says Bryan Stiger, CFP, a financial advisor at Betterments 401.
If you dont meet any of those qualifications, you arent entirely out of luck, though. Youve got a couple of options that may let you make penalty-free withdrawals, if youre slightly younger than retirement age or plan your withdrawals methodically.
If youre between age 55 and 59 ½ and you lose your job, the IRS will allow you to withdraw from your 401 plan penalty-free. This is called the Rule of 55, and it applies to everyone within this age group who loses a job, no matter whether youre fired, laid off or voluntarily quit. Stiger says. To qualify for the Rule of 55, the 401 you hope to take withdrawals from must be at the company youve just parted ways with. Note that the Rule of 55 does not apply to IRAs.
There is also the Substantially Equal Periodic Payment exemption, or an IRS Section 72 distribution, say Stiger. With SEPP you can take substantially equal payments from your 401 based on life expectancy. Unlike the Rule of 55, you may use SEPPs to tap an IRA early.
Don’t Miss: How To Borrow From 401k To Buy A House
Key Considerations With 401 Loans
- Some plans permit up to two loans at a time, but most plans allow only one and require it be paid off before requesting another one.
- Your plan may also require that you obtain consent from your spouse/domestic partner.
- You will be required to make regularly scheduled repayments consisting of both principal and interest, typically through payroll deduction.
- Loans must be paid back within five years .
- If you leave your job and have an outstanding 401 balance, youll have to pay the loan back within a certain amount of time or be subject to tax and early withdrawal penalties.
- The money you use to pay yourself back is done with after-tax dollars.
Although getting a loan from your 401 is relatively quick and easy, the benefit of paying yourself back with interest will likely not make up for the return on investment you could have earned if your funds had remained invested.
Another risk: If your financial situation does not improve and you fail to pay the loan back, it will likely result in penalties and interest.
Leave Your Retirement Savings In Your Former Qrp If The Qrp Allows
While this approach requires nothing of you in the short term, managing multiple retirement accounts can be cumbersome and confusing in the long run. And, you will continue to be subject to the QRPs rules regarding investment choices, distribution options, and loan availability. If you choose to leave your savings with your former employer, remember to periodically review your investments and carefully track associated account documents and information.
Features
- Your former employer may not allow you to keep your assets in the plan.
- You must maintain a relationship with your former employer, possibly for decades.
- You generally are allowed to repay an outstanding loan within a short period of time.
- Additional contributions are generally not allowed. In addition to ordinary income tax, distributions prior to age 59½ may be subject to a 10% additional tax.
- RMDs, from your former employers plan, begin April 1 following the year you reach age 72 and continue annually thereafter, to avoid IRS penalties.
- RMDs must be taken from each QRP including designated Roth accounts aggregation is not allowed.
- Not all employer-sponsored plans have bankruptcy and creditor protection under ERISA.
If you choose this option, remember to periodically review your investments, carefully track associated paperwork and documents, and take RMDs from each of your retirement accounts.
Read Also: How To Transfer My 401k To My Bank Account
Roth Ira Conversion Ladder
Another way to access your retirement fund is through the Roth IRA conversion. You can build a Roth IRA ladder and withdraw without having to pay the 10% penalty.
Just repeat this every year until youre 59 ½.
The drawback here is you have to wait 5 years before you can take out the first chunk of money without penalty. The 5 years wait only applies to Roth IRA conversion. If you contribute to your Roth IRA outside of a conversion, then you can withdraw that contribution anytime without paying the 10% penalty.
Withdrawing Funds From A 401 At 55
The rule of 55 allows 401 participants to withdraw money from the retirement plan penalty-free at age 55. The IRS requires that an employee must have left their employer, either by being laid off, fired, or simply quitting, in the calendar year they turn 55 to get a penalty-free distribution. If you lost your job at 54, you do not qualify to withdraw money tax-free from the 401 when you attain age 55.
The Rule of 55 does not apply to the old 401s left with former employers it only applies to the current 401 with your current employer. If you still have money in the old 401s of a former employer, and you were not yet 55 when you left, the rule of 55 does not apply. You will have to wait until you are 59 ½ to start taking withdrawals from the old 401s without paying a penalty tax. Still, you can roll over the old 401s into your current 401 before you are 55 so that you can take a distribution penalty-free.
Don’t Miss: What Is The Tax Rate On 401k Withdrawals
What Happens If I Have Unclaimed 401 Funds From A Previous Job
The majority of unclaimed money comes from brokerage, checking, and savings accounts, along with annuities, 401s, and Individual Retirement Accounts. Once an account is considered inactive or dormant for a period of time , companies are required by law to mail abandoned funds to the owners last known address. If theyre returned, or the owner cant be reached, the assets must be relinquished to the state.
Early Withdrawal Age Rules Only Apply To The Assets In The 401 Plan Maintained By Your Former Employer
Assets in an IRA have their own rules regarding a penalty-free early withdrawal. In a similar vein, assets that youve rolled over from your 401 to an IRA will generally no longer be eligible for penalty-free early withdrawals unless you qualify for a different exemption . If theres a possibility you may need to tap into the savings in your 401, you may want to hold off on rolling those assets over to an IRA until you turn 59 ½.
Also Check: What Should I Do With My Old Company 401k
Withdrawing Funds From A 401 Before 55
If you are younger than 55, you may still qualify to withdraw money without quitting your current job. You can take a hardship withdrawal if you have a qualified expense. For example, you can take a hardship withdrawal to pay qualified educational fees, medical expenses, alimony and child support, repair of damage to your residence or to purchase your principal residence. You will owe income tax on the amount you take out from your retirement savings as a hardship withdrawal.
Option : Do A Rollover To An Ira And Take Control Of It
An IRA is an account you can set up on your own as opposed to a 401 which is sponsored by your employer. As noted above, you can rollover your 401 to an IRA once you leave your employer. If you decide to pursue this route, you can opt to rollover your funds to either a traditional IRA or Roth IRA.
If your contributions to your 401 were pre-tax, rolling over to a traditional IRA may be the simpler and preferred option because it will have no tax consequences. Your assets will continue to grow tax-deferred and be taxed on the distributions when you retire. See tax details further down in the article. Traditional 401s and IRAs also have Required Minimum Distributions when you reach 70 ½.
Another option is to rollover to a Roth IRA. If you opted for a Roth 401, again this will have no tax consequence except for any employer match amount, which is always pre-tax. But if you opted for a pre-tax 401, rolling into a Roth IRA will cause a large tax consequence – youll owe immediate tax on the contributions and growth. The main advantage of a Roth IRA is that you wont have to pay taxes on qualified distributions when you retire because the funds have already been taxed and grow tax-free. Sometimes it makes sense to rollover to a Roth IRA in a year when you have a low income because the potential gain in tax-free growth on the assets may be greater than the one-time tax hit.
You May Like: Is It Good To Invest In 401k
Scenario : Monthly Pension
If you receive distributions as a monthly pension, you should check about the status of a tax treaty between the US and your home country. In most cases, you will only have to pay taxes in the country where you are a resident. If you have moved back to India, for instance, you only have to pay taxes in India when you receive your monthly 401 pension. However, you may still be required to file US tax returns. If there is no treaty between the US and your home country, the brokerage has to withhold 30% from the monthly distributions.
Since taxation rules and requirements differ from one country to another, it would be best to consult a tax advisor like MYRA prior to your move to help you create a strategy.
Related Article: When Is It Ok To Withdraw Money Early From Your 401?
If Youve Already Taken A Withdrawal Or Loan You Can Recover
Stay calm and make steady progress toward recovery. It can be done. Build up a cushion of at least three to nine months of your income. No matter what incremental amount you save to get there, Poorman says, the key detail is consistency and regularity. For instance, have the sum automatically deposited to a savings account so you cant skip it.
Scale back daily expenses. Keep your compact car with 120,000 miles and drive it less often to your favorite steakhouse or fashion boutique.
Save aggressively to your 401 plan as soon as possible and stay on track. Bump up your 401 contribution 1% annually, until you maximize your retirement savings. Sock away the money earned from any job promotion or raise.
Also Check: How To Manage 401k Investments
Alternatives To Rule Of 55 Withdrawals
The rule of 55, which doesnt apply to traditional or Roth IRAs, isnt the only way to get money from your retirement plan early. For example, you wont pay the penalty if you take distributions early because:
- You become totally and permanently disabled.
- You pass away and your beneficiary or estate is withdrawing money from the plan.
- Youre taking distributions to pay deductible medical expenses that exceed 7.5% of your adjusted gross income.
- Distributions are the result of an IRS levy.
- Youre receiving qualified reservist distributions.
You can also avoid the 10% early withdrawal penalty if early distributions are made as part of a series of substantially equal periodic payments, known as a SEPP plan. You have to be separated from service to qualify for this exception if youre taking money from an employers plan, but youre not subject to the 55 or older requirement. The payment amounts youd receive come from your life expectancy.
Taking The 10% Early Withdrawal Penalty Plus Taxes And Withdrawing Early From A Retirement Account May Put You In Better Position Than Investing In A Standard Brokerage Account
If you are saving for the long-term and your income allows you to contribute to a tax deferred account ), you may want to consider actually paying the 10% penalty and taxes if the previous options arent available or feasible for you. In many cases, you may still come out ahead compared to skipping the initial tax deferral and investing in a taxable investment account. This will depend on your tax rates, so make sure to run your projected numbers.
The big conclusion here though is that waiting until age 59½ is not the only viable option for retirees with savings.
IRA, 401, 457, and 403 plans are more flexible than many people realize. If youre saving for the purpose of retirement or semi-retirement, you may want to exhaust all other tax advantaged options before investing with a taxable account.
However, taxable accounts can still be a valuable option if your income level makes you ineligible for tax-advantaged accounts, or if you are investing for a shorter-term goal.
With these conclusions in mind, you can feel confident and prepared to evaluate retirement account types and bridge the gap when you reach early retirement age.
Further reading and references:
Also Check: Should I Convert My 401k To A Roth Ira
Ask Bob: Can I Make A Lump
Question
If I didn’t contribute to a 401 during 2021, but was eligible to do so, can I do a lump sum contribution? Does it have to be before the end of the year?
Answer
It depends on the provisions of the 401 plan, says Denise Appleby, the CEO of Appleby Retirement Consulting.
A key determining factor is whether the terms of the 401 plan allow you to make a salary deferral election now, she says. Generally, the election is made during your enrollment period. Some plans do provide multiple windows during the year, and some provide only one window.
If you are eligible to make a deferral election now, how much you are eligible to defer is determined by the terms of the arrangement, says Appleby. Generally, salary deferral contributions are based on a percentage of salary, she says.
For example, the salary deferral election form provided by your employer might require that you elect to contribute up to 100% of your compensation or a dollar amount. Either would be capped at a total of $19,500 for the year 2021. In some cases, the percentage is less than 100.
Some plans, says Appleby, will also allow you to make catch-up contributions of up to $6,500 if you are at least age 50 by the end of the year.
Limited Access To Your 401 After You Leave
Although your former employer cannot refuse to give you your 401 funds without just cause after you leave, you can find yourself unable to access them.
As mentioned before, if you have an outstanding 401 loan when you leave your job, you may be required to pay back the full balance of the loan within 60 days.
Employers can refuse access to your 401 until you repay your 401 loan.
Additionally, if there are any other lingering financial discrepancies between you and your former employer, they may put on your 401 hold.
Recommended Reading: Should You Move Your 401k To An Ira
When Can I Withdraw From My 401 Before Retirement But Without Tax Penalties
You don’t have to be in retirement to start withdrawing money from your 401. However, there are penalties involved depending on your age. If you wait until after you are 59 1/2, you can withdraw without any penalties. If you can’t wait until you are 59 1/2, then you will experience a 10% penalty on the amount withdrawn.
Option : Leave Your 401 Where It Is
Even if you are returning to your home country, you can choose to leave your 401 with your employer in the US until you reach the age of 59 ½. This will help you defer taxes until withdrawal or accumulate tax-free growth if you selected a Roth 401. Some employers wont allow you to leave your 401 behind especially if your balance is less than $1,000. From the day you leave your job, you have 60 days to decide if you want to roll over your 401 to IRA.
Related Article: Whats The Difference Between A 401 and an IRA?
Leaving your 401 as is can have some downsides. Within a 401 plan, your investment options may be limited. In addition, if your employer decides to terminate the plan, youll have either withdraw the funds or rollover the funds to an individual retirement account . Make sure that your 401 plan can communicate with you by email or mail once you have returned to your home country so that you get adequate notice of any changes. And keep track of your 401s over your lifetime, as you may have several employers and it can be hard to keep track of all the plan sponsors and logins.
Related Article: The Tax Trick That Will Get An Extra $37,000 Into Your Roth IRA Every Year
You May Like: How To Get Money Out Of 401k Without Paying Taxes
