When An Ira Is Better
An IRA could be better than a 401 if youre looking for more flexibility in your retirement planning.
Unlike a 401, with an IRA the investment world is at your fingertips, says Taylor J Kovar, Certified Financial Planner and CEO of Kovar Wealth Management. Stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and real estate are all available while with a 401, you are limited to just the funds the plan allows you to invest in.
Another reason why an IRA could be a better option is if you currently have low tax rates but anticipate higher tax rates during retirement. By contributing to a Roth IRA, youll pay your taxes upfront so your growth and withdrawals during retirement are tax-free.
Not all employers offer a 401 plan, so an IRA is one of the best alternatives to help you save for retirement on your own.
Vs Roth : Which One Is Better
11 Minute Read | November 12, 2021
If youve heard of a Roth 401, you may be wondering how different it really is from a traditional 401. We get it, 401s can be confusing! While these two types of 401 accounts have some similarities, they also have some pretty huge differences.
Access to a Roth option is becoming more and more common, so youre in the majority if you have this option at work. Just over the last five years, the number of plans offering a Roth 401 option has increased by 32%. As of 2021, about 3 out of 4 workplace retirement plans now offer a Roth optionwhich is great news for you!1
And guess what? Younger savers are starting to take advantage of this new option. Millennials are the most likely group to contribute to their Roth 401 at work.2
If you can contribute to a Roth and traditional 401 at work, which one should you choose? Lets dig into some of the differences between these options so you can make the best decision.
Vs Roth : How Are They Different
The biggest difference between a traditional 401 and a Roth 401 is how the money you contribute is taxed. Taxes can be kind of confusing , so lets start with a simple definition and then well dive into the details.
A Roth 401 is a post-tax retirement savings account. That means your contributions have already been taxed before they enter your Roth account.
On the other hand, a traditional 401 is a pretax savings account. When you invest in a traditional 401, your contributions go in before theyre taxed, which makes your taxable income lower.
Roth 401 vs. Traditional 401: Pros and Cons
|Contributions||Contributions are made with after-tax dollars .||Contributions are made with pre-tax dollars .|
|Withdrawals||The money you put in and its growth are not taxed. However, your employer match is subject to taxes.||All withdrawals will be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate. Most state income taxes apply too.|
|Access||If youve held the account for at least five years, you can start taking money out once you are age 59 1/2. You or your beneficiaries can also receive distributions due to disability or death.||You can start receiving distributions at age 59 1/2, no matter how long youve had your 401. You or your beneficiaries can also receive distributions due to disability or death.|
You May Like: Is A 401k A Defined Benefit Plan
Guaranteed Vs Variable Income
The big difference between a pension and 401 thatâs invested in the stock market is that the former provides a guaranteed income stream, while the latter will provide an income stream but from a balance that varies with the market. In retirement itâs good to have a mix of both to help manage different risks.
Income streams exposed to markets increases risk but allows you to potentially capture upside and collect dividends to temper inflation risks. Guaranteed income streams, like a pension, are steady and will last a lifetime. Guaranteed income reduces exposure to market volatility and longevity risk in a financial plan.
How To Make A 401 And Roth Ira Work Together
At this point, you may ask whether you should put your money in a 401 or a Roth IRA. The answer is yes.
If youre eligible for a 401 and a Roth IRA, the best-case scenario is that you invest in both accounts . That way, youre taking advantage of your employer match and getting the tax benefits of a Roth IRA.
Heres how that works in three simple steps: Lets say you make $60,000 a year and youre under 50. Your goal is to invest 15%$9,000 in this casein retirement.
- You start by investing in your 401 up to the match that your company offers. Lets say, in this case, that its 3% of your gross income . You invest $1,800 in your 401 to reach the employer match. This leaves you with $7,200 more to invest.
- Then, you max out your Roth IRA. You can only contribute $6,000, so that leaves you with $1,200.
- Return to your 401 and invest the remaining $1,200.
Remember, if youre older than 50, there are catch-up contributions you can make to max out your Roth IRA at $7,000 and your 401 at $26,000.
You may be wondering what you should do if your employer doesnt offer a 401 and youve maxed out your Roth IRA for the year. The short answer? You need your money to grow. You can still work with an investment pro to invest in growth stock mutual funds that arent connected with a retirement account. After you invest your money, leave it alone. Investing is a marathonnot a sprint.
Read Also: When Can I Move My 401k To An Ira
How Are Annuities And 401s Different
A 401 plan is only available to employees whose employers offer them. On the flips side, anyone can purchase an annuity. Contributing to a 401 is impossible if your employer doesnt offer one. However, self-employed individuals can set up their own 401s.
Another key difference? Fees.
Checking the fees, you pay for your 401 is typically relatively easy. First, request an explanation of any fees charged to your account from your plan administrator. Its often more challenging to figure out how much annuity fees will cost you. Additionally, fees for annuities, benefit riders, and more may be steep.
Other distinctions between annuities and 401s include
When A 401 Is A Good Choice
All this isn’t to say that 401s never have their place in your investment strategy. While Roth IRAs do boast several key benefits, the 401 does have its merits as well.
For one, many 401s offer matching contributions from your employer. Matching contributions are basically free cash that you can collect just by saving in your 401, and they’re a perk you won’t find with an IRA. If you have access to employer matching contributions, it may be wise to invest enough in your 401 to earn the full match. Then you can invest the rest of your savings in a Roth IRA.
In addition, you’re allowed to save more per year in a 401 than in a Roth IRA. For 2021, you can contribute up to $19,500 per year in a 401 and $6,000 per year in an IRA. For those over age 50, you can contribute $6,500 per year in your 401 and $1,000 per year in your IRA. If you’re a super saver, you might choose to max out your Roth IRA first and then stash the rest of your savings in a 401.
While each retirement account has its advantages and disadvantages, the Roth IRA outshines the 401 in a few areas. By investing strategically and choosing the right account for you, it will be easier to build a healthy nest egg by retirement age.
Is Roth Ira Better Than 401k
In many circumstances, a Roth IRA is a better option than a 401 retirement plan because it provides a more flexible investment vehicle with more tax advantagesespecially if you expect to be in a higher tax band in the future. A 401 is hard to beat if your income is too high to contribute to a Roth, your employer matches your contributions, and you want to save more money each year.
Having both a 401 and a Roth IRA is an excellent approach . Invest up to the matching limit in your 401, then finance a Roth up to the contribution limit. Any remaining money can then be applied to your 401 contribution limit.
Still, because everyones financial position is unique, its a good idea to do some research before making any judgments. When in doubt, consult a knowledgeable financial advisor who can provide answers to any queries you may have.
Why We Recommend The Roth 401
If youre investing consistently every monthwhether its in a Roth 401, a traditional 401 or even a Roth IRAyoure already on the right track! The most important part of wealth building is consistent saving every month, no matter what the market is doing.
But if choosing between a traditional 401 and a Roth 401, we’d go with the Roth every time! Weve already talked through the differences between these two types of accounts, so youre probably already seeing the benefits. But just to be clear, here are the biggest reasons the Roth comes out on top.
Also Check: Can I Roll A Roth Ira Into A 401k
Its Not Only About Taxes
Taxes are important, and theyâre the primary factor in this debate. But there are other points to consider:
Whether youre eligible for a Roth IRA.Roth IRAs have income limits Roth 401s do not. If you earn too much to be eligible for the Roth IRA, the Roth 401 is a chance to get access to the Roths tax-free investment growth.
Certain income thresholds in retirement. Taking some of your retirement income from a Roth can lower your gross income in the eyes of the IRS, which may in turn lower your retirement expenses. A lower income in retirement may reduce the taxes you pay on your Social Security benefits and the cost of your Medicare premiums that are tied to income.
Access to your retirement money. Unfortunately, the Roth 401 doesnt have the flexibility of a Roth IRA you canât remove contributions at any time. In fact, in some ways its less flexible than a traditional 401, due to that five-year rule: Even if you hit age 59Â½, your distribution wont be qualified unless youve also held the account at least five years. Thats something to keep in mind if youre getting a late start.
Required minimum distributions in retirement. Both accounts require account owners to begin taking distributions at age 72, but money in a Roth 401 can easily be rolled into a Roth IRA, which will then allow you to avoid those distributions and even pass that money on to heirs.
Ira Vs : Which Is Better For You
Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure for more information.
IRA vs. 401 whats the difference, and which is better for you? IRAs and 401s are two different retirement plans that allow individuals to invest and save for retirement. Saving in either is a great way to set money aside for retirement because they both have valuable tax benefits and offer potential investment gains.
The simplest way to differentiate these two retirement plans is to understand that a 401 is available to you through your employer, and an IRA is something you set up for yourself.
Both of these plans grow tax-free, which means theres no tax on the interest and earning over the years, and that makes them a great way to set money aside for your golden years.
Ready to learn more? Lets get started!
Dont Miss: How To Select 401k Investments
Recommended Reading: Where Is My Fidelity 401k Account Number
A Roth 401k Is Usually Better Early In Your Career
If you are wise enough to start saving when you are young, you probably expect your income to increase by a great deal long before the end of your career. In that case, your retirement income might exceed your current income, so you want to pay your taxes now.
Later in your career, a traditional 401K is usually a better idea. An average retired person’s taxable income is usually lower than their income was late in their career.
One fortunate thing about retirement saving is that you can contribute to both a traditional 401K and a Roth 401K. This way, you can put money into a Roth 401K when you are younger and into a traditional 401K when you are older and expect your income to decrease after retirement. When estimating your post-retirement income, make sure you take social security payments and everything else into consideration.
In 2020, you can only contribute $19500 per year to your 401K accounts before you turn 50. While you could theoretically contribute to both a traditional 401K and a Roth 401K each year, you could only contribute $9750 to each account, and not $19500 to each account. Being able to open both types of accounts is advantageous because you might use one account when you are younger and another account when you are older and have a better income.
Borrowing Money From Your Own 401k Funds
If you have a Roth 401K, and you cannot withdraw any money yet, not even as an early withdrawal, you might be able to borrow money from your 401K account and pay it back later. With a traditional 401K, you do not have this advantage.
Taking out one of these loans is risky because if you end up losing your job, you will have to pay the loan off shortly. Taking out one of these loans is risky. However, it is still an advantage to have this option, as long as you are careful with it.
Recommended Reading: How Much Can I Withdraw From My 401k
How To Get Started Investing In Either Iras Or 401s
If you want a 401 plan, check to see what your employer offers. You can only get a 401 plan through your job. The HR department is a good place to start looking for information about 401 plans at your work.
If you want an IRA, all you need to do is open an account with a broker. Figure out which IRA is best for you . Deposit your money and make sure its invested.
IRAs and 401s are not mutually exclusive you can get both.
A Roth Ira Doesnt Have Required Minimum Distributions
Did you know that the IRS will force you to start taking money out of your 401k when you turn 72?
A required minimum distribution is the minimum amount you are required to withdraw from certain retirement accounts.
This amount depends on a lot of factors, but ultimately it means that you arent allowed to leave your retirement investments alone and let them compound indefinitely.
The IRS requires you to begin taking distrubutions from your 401k at age 72, even if you are still working or dont need the funds just yet!
When you withdraw from a traditional 401k, youll also pay income tax on the amount withdrawn.
The IRS doesnt want you to get rich from perpetual compounding and avoiding income taxes for too long
This is your money that you worked hard to save, and now you dont even get to decide when to withdraw it?
I know that most of us will probably be planning to use money from our 401ks by the time were 72, so this probably wont affect you too much unless you have a ton of other passive income and dont need to tap the 401k just yet.
But this rule is pretty annoying and can change your retirement strategy to optimize for tax expenses.
The cool thing about theRoth IRA is that there are no required minimum distributions.
You already paid the IRS when you put the money in the account, so they dont care when you use the money .
Youll have full control over your money and when you withdraw it. Pretty neat!
Recommended Reading: Can I Roll A 401k Into An Existing Ira
Youre Our First Priorityevery Time
NerdWallet, Inc. is an independent publisher and comparison service, not an investment advisor. Its articles, interactive tools and other content are provided to you for free, as self-help tools and for informational purposes only. They are not intended to provide investment advice. NerdWallet does not and cannot guarantee the accuracy or applicability of any information in regard to your individual circumstances. Examples are hypothetical, and we encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding specific investment issues. Our estimates are based on past market performance, and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance.
We believe everyone should be able to make financial decisions with confidence. And while our site doesnt feature every company or financial product available on the market, were proud that the guidance we offer, the information we provide and the tools we create are objective, independent, straightforward and free.
So how do we make money? Our partners compensate us. This may influence which products we review and write about , but it in no way affects our recommendations or advice, which are grounded in thousands of hours of research. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable reviews of their products or services.Here is a list of our partners.
Ira Vs : The Quick Answer
Both 401s and IRAs have valuable tax benefits, and you can contribute to both at the same time. The main difference between 401s and IRAs is that employers offer 401s, but individuals open IRAs . IRAs typically offer more investments 401s allow higher annual contributions.
If the IRA vs. 401 comparison is weighing on you, heres the quick answer:
If your employer offers a 401 with a company match: Consider putting enough money in your 401 to get the maximum match. That match may offer a 100% return on your money, depending on the 401. For example, some employers promise a 100% match up to 3% of salary. That means, if your salary is $50,000, your employer will put in $1,500, as long as you also contribute at least $1,500. Once you get the match, then consider maxing out an IRA for the year, return to the 401 and resume contributions there.
If your employer doesnt offer a company match: Consider skipping the 401 at first and start with an IRA or Roth IRA. You’ll get access to a large selection of investments when you open your IRA at a broker, and you’ll avoid the administrative fees that some 401s charge. After contributing up to the IRA limit, think about funding your 401 for the pre-tax benefit it offers. Here’s how and where to open an IRA.
Here’s more on the pros and cons of the IRA vs. 401 question:
» Want to turn a 401 into an IRA? See our guide to rollover IRAs
You May Like: How To Check Your 401k Account