Pros And Cons Of 401 Brokerage Options
Expanded investment choices make this self-directed approach a double-edged sword for 401 investors.
|For more news you can use to help guide your financial life, visit our Insights page.|
Important legal information about the e-mail you will be sending.
Content for this page, unless otherwise indicated with a Fidelity pyramid logo, is selected and published by Fidelity Interactive Content Services LLC , a Fidelity company. All Web pages published by FICS will contain this legend.Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC Before investing, consider the funds’ investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses. Contact Fidelity for a prospectus or, if available, a summary prospectus containing this information. Read it carefully.
Choose Your Asset Mix Carefully
Its essential to think about your asset mix, which simply means the different types of investments that go into your portfolio. For example, investing in stocks may help you grow your retirement fund faster, but if they drop substantially, you could also see plenty of losses. Thats why its essential to choose your asset mix wisely and make sure there are different types of investments in your portfolio.
Some tips about how to choose assets are:
Invest more in stocks when youre young.
When deciding how to allocate your funds, a general rule of thumb is that the younger you are, the more you can invest in stocks. This is because stocks offer much higher returns than other assets and have always shown a historical tendency to go up. However, they can also crash the hardest, which is unacceptable for someone who is reaching retirement age.
However, if youre young, you can afford to take on more risk and even some temporary losses because its almost a certainty that stocks will end up climbing again in the future. If you keep a long-term mindset, youre bound to end up winning in the end.
As you get older, choose safer investments.
Investing in low-cost index funds will provide you with an average return without taking on too much risk. But if you really want to reduce risk as much as possible, investing in bonds or bond funds rather than stocks or stock funds is the way to go.
How Can A Stock Market Crash Affect Your 401
One of the best things about 401 is that it gives employees the freedom to invest on their terms. But even with such an advantage, a crash can affect savings. Thus, it helps to understand where to put 401 before the market crashes and why.
Many investment options for the 401 retirement plan include stocks, bonds, and cash.
Often, in earlier stages of employment, stocks account for most of the 401 investments. With proper asset allocation, the stock-bond ratio should change over the years to mitigate risks.
However, stocks remain a popular investment choice thanks to their high returns. While thats a tremendous advantage when prices follow an upward trajectory, an unexpected stock market crash can do a lot of damage.
The 2008 financial collapse is one of the cleanest examples of the markets devastating impact on corresponding 401 retirement plan assets. More than 21 million participants endured changes in average 401 balances from January 1, 2008, to January 20, 2009. And the only distinction, depending on the participants account balance, was the amount lost.
The best-case scenario is suffering losses that the employee can recover from in the following years. The worst-case scenario is wiping out years, even decades worth of savings. So, its crucial to keep a close eye on the different investment options to avoid or cut down potential losses over a stock market crash.
Recommended Reading: How Much Can I Borrow Against My 401k
How We Make Money
The offers that appear on this site are from companies that compensate us. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site, including, for example, the order in which they may appear within the listing categories. But this compensation does not influence the information we publish, or the reviews that you see on this site. We do not include the universe of companies or financial offers that may be available to you.
Scale Up Contributions Over Time
Once you’ve picked your investments, the best thing you can do is leave your account alone and let the contributions build.
In addition to low costs and diversity, consistently investing over time i.e., every paycheck will make the biggest difference in the size of your savings. Low-cost funds are only effective if you continuously invest in them and don’t try to time the market, or pull money out when it starts to drop, a recent report from Morningstar says.
Experts also advise increasing your contributions each time you get a raise or bonus by a percentage point or two, helping you reach your goals faster.
Finally, remember that while the stock market has historically increased around 10% per year, that’s not guaranteed, and there will be periods when it falls. Experts also expect returns to be lower, around 4%, over the next decade than they have been the previous 10 years.
Still, no one knows what will happen, except that the best course of action is typically to invest in low-cost index funds consistently, over many decades. Do that, and you’ll be on the path to building real wealth.
Don’t Miss: How To Roll My 401k Into An Ira
Other Unique Features Of Brokerage Accounts
Invest for non-retirement goals. With a 401, IRA, or Roth IRA, there are limits as to when you can use the fundsand for what purposewithout incurring a penalty. With a brokerage account, there are no such restrictions . Any money you need access to in the short-term should be kept in a high-yield savings account, but for goals with an intermediate or long-term time frame a brokerage account can be a great solution.
Avoid required minimum distributions. Just as there are no rules on how early you can access the funds, there are also no regulations on when you must begin tapping the account, as with Traditional IRAs, 401s, pension plans, and so forth. This is important as retirees who dont need the income can avoid unnecessary tax consequences, fees, and the disruption to their portfolio by staying invested.
Tax-efficient way to leave a legacy. The tax rules change when a beneficiary inherits a taxable brokerage account. If the original account owner sells a position during their life, the difference between their cost basis in the investment and the sale price will determine the gain thats subject to capital gains taxes . When an investor has highly appreciated securities in a taxable account, there may be a significant tax liability if the position is sold. However, if your spouse or heirs inherit a taxable brokerage account, the assets can pass on a stepped-up cost basis, which steps-up their inherited cost basis in the asset to the value on the date of your death.
Pros Of Investing In Stocks Include:
Ability to Create a Personalized Portfolio
You can invest in any company or company you please within the limits of your available funds. This allows you to tailor your portfolio to match your specific risk tolerance and time horizon.
Higher Potential Returns
Stocks have notably offered a higher rate of return than the average mutual fund, but this may not be true in the future.
Higher Potential for Loss
Stocks are riskier investments than 401 accounts or low-risk mutual funds since they offer a higher rate of return. This also means you could potentially lose your entire investment.
Read Also: What Percent Should You Put In 401k
Mistake #: Failing To Take Full Advantage Of Retirement Saving Plans
If your companys 401 or other qualified employer sponsored retirement plan , including 403 and governmental 457, offers a company match , you have an extra incentive. If you neglect to invest enough to receive the full company match, youre leaving money on the table. If you get a raise, consider increasing your QRP contribution.
Convert Old 401s To Roth Iras
Lets pretend that youve changed jobs at least once in your career, and you still have a 401 from a former employer. If you have enough cash on hand, you can convert that 401 into a Roth IRA. Since the money in that 401 wasnt taxed when you first put it into the account, youll pay taxes on that money when you convert it to a Roth IRA. Doing that rollover is not complicated. Youll have to make some phone calls and fill out some paperwork.
Why would you want to convert that old 401 into a Roth IRA? There are a couple of reasons.
Remember this: converting is an option only if you have the cash on hand to pay the taxes. If you dont have enough, try Door #3.
Don’t Miss: How Do I Access My 401k Account
For Mutual Fund Investors: Qtrade*
At a flat rate of $8.75 per trade, Qtrade* charges a higher commission on stocks and ETFs than Questrade, but it eliminates commissions on mutual funds, which might be a savvy trade-off for those looking to invest in their RRSPs this way. Theres a $25 administration fee billed quarterly, but if you establish recurring deposits or hold a minimum of $25,000, you can get a waiver. Qtrade* enjoys a reputation for offering stellar customer service and great investment tools for seasoned investors and helpful educational guides for newbies.
A note-worthy perk: When new and existing clients open a new Qtrade account and deposit/transfer at least $15,000 in assets , they can earn up to $2,000 cash back.
- Account fees: $25 per quarter
- Commissions: $0 when buying/selling mutual funds $8.75 per trade for most equities
What Happens To My 401 Plan Account If I Change Jobs
If you switch jobs, you may want to transfer your old 401 plan account into your new employers plan known as a rollover, or roll-in. But not all employers will allow a rollover. If you dont want to roll your account over or you cant, you may have several options:
- Stay with your old plan
If your account balance is above a certain level , your previous employer may give you the option to keep your investments in its plan.
- Move your savings
You can roll over the money into an individual retirement account . This may or may not be the right option for you, depending on several factors, including fees and how the IRAs investment options compare to your old and new employers 401 plans.
- Cash out your savings
If none of the above options appeals to you, you could take a distribution for the full amount of your old 401 in cash, subject to taxes and penalties.
Don’t Miss: How Long Do I Have To Transfer My 401k
Your Plan May Allow You To But That Doesn’t Mean You Should
One of the biggest disadvantages of 401s is that you’re usually limited to a few investment options that have been selected by your employer and may or may not fit your needs. Historically, most workers had no other choice if they wanted to contribute to their 401s, but the rising popularity of 401 self-directed brokerage accounts is changing this.
More options aren’t always better, though, especially if you’re new to investing and are unsure what to choose. Below, I explain 401 brokerage accounts in more detail, along with who may want to consider them and who is better off staying away.
How To Protect Your 401 From A Stock Market Crash
Stock market crashes are impossible to predict. However, you can protect your 401 from losing money if the market does crash.
Making sure you have enough money for retirement is the primary goal of contributing to a 401. Your 401 will inevitably go through a series of ebbs and flows throughout your working years. Some years youâll see tremendous growth, others you may even lose money. However, as you near retirement, youâll want to protect your 401 from down years, even a stock market crash.
To protect your 401 from stock market crash, invest more in bond, which has a lower rate of return but also much lower risk. To gain as much value as you can, investments heavier in stocks give you the best chance of multiplying your money. However, with stocks comes increased risk. Shifting the percentage of your investments to a more bond-heavy allocation can help shield you if the stock market crashes as you get closer to retirement.
Capturing as much of the good times as possible while avoiding significant losses isnât an exact science there are strategies to help shift the odds in your favor. Letâs take a look at the basics of investing your 401, so you can protect your retirement nest egg.
Also Check: Why Move 401k To Ira
Should I Invest My 401 In Individual Stocks
Individual stocks can have unlimited upside and dont come with management fees. So are they a good bet for your 401? Heres how you can decide whether stocks are right for your 401 and limit the risks associated with them.
Please note: This article assumes that your 401 comes with the option to invest in individual stocks, but many plans do not.
Know thyselfTheres no question that investing in individual companies can grant your retirement account returns that even the market cant touch. Warren Buffet has made a career of picking companies to invest in, and you might be tempted to do the same within the tax-deferred auspices of your 401.
But should you?
The main challenge of stock-picking is, well, picking stocks. To be successful requires nerve, research, and extraordinary patience. Do you enjoy analyzing individual companies? Do you have the patience and risk tolerance for it?
If you can choose critically and stand by your choices, you can add potential upside to your 401, especially given its tax-deferred status. But if you have a tendency to chase fads and rotate in and out of positions, youll probably do more harm than good.
This process is critical especially for something as important as retirement. While your S& P 500 index fund can lose a lot of money at a time, its not in and of itself going to go bankrupt. Eventually, it will climb back up, which is the whole point of a long-term investment outlook .
How To Manage Your 401 In A Bear Market
When a bear market sets in, the worst thing you can do is hit the panic button on your 401. While it may be disheartening to see your account value decreasing as stock prices drop, thats not necessarily a reason to overhaul your asset allocation.
Instead, look at which investments are continuing to perform well, if any. And consider how much of a decline youre seeing in your investments overall. Look closely at how much of your 401 you have invested in your own companys stock, as this could be a potential trouble spot if your company takes a financial hit as the result of a downturn.
Continue making contributions to your 401, at least at the minimum level to receive your employers full company match. If you can afford to do so, you may also consider increasing your contribution rate. This could allow you to max out your annual contribution limit while purchasing new investments at a discount when the market is down. Rebalance your investments in your 401 as needed to stay aligned with your financial goals, risk tolerance and timeline for retiring.
Recommended Reading: Does Borrowing From 401k Affect Credit Score
Trade Stocks In A Solo 401k Plan
Now you have an understanding of how convenient it is holding a stock brokerage account inside of your Solo 401k. With that, youre going to want to know about strategies available inside the brokerage account. Coming soon is Part 2 of this blog that will cover more in-depth topics including:
- How do I trade options?
- Can I buy futures in my retirement plan?
- How do I short stocks in a Solo 401k?
- Can you do uncovered calls in a retirement plan?
- Can I buy LEAPS in a retirement plan?
Perhaps you are currently most comfortable investing in stocks and bonds. In the future it may be worth expanding your vision to learn about alternative investments like real estate or bitcoin. Or perhaps youre already highly experienced with alternative investments. For diversification, youd like to cast an even wider net for your portfolio that includes a brokerage account. A Solo 401k is the one account that puts you in full control of when, where, and how you want to invest.
Determine How Much You Can Contribute
Workers under 50 can contribute up to $19,500 to a 401 in 2020, but how much you actually earmark for the account depends on your income, debt level and other financial goals. Still, financial experts advise contributing as much as you are able to, ideally between 10% to 15% of your income, especially when you are young: The sooner you start investing, the less youll have to save each month to reach your goals, thanks to compound interest.
Thats your company literally saying: Hey, heres some free money, do you want to take it?’ financial expert Ramit Sethi told CNBC Make It. If you dont take that, youre making a huge mistake.
Read Also: Should I Open A 401k
Read Also: Where To Put 401k After Retirement