Risks Of Taking Out A 401 Loan
Before deciding to borrow money from your 401, keep in mind that doing so has its drawbacks.
You may not get one. Having the option to get a 401 loan depends on your employer and the plan they have set up. A 2020 study from retirement data firm BrightScope and the Investment Company Institute says that 78 percent of plans gave participants the option to borrow based on 2017 data. So you may need to seek funds elsewhere.
You have limits. You might not be able to access as much cash as you need. The maximum loan amount is $50,000 or 50 percent of your vested account balance, whichever is less.
Old 401s dont count. If youre planning on tapping into a 401 from a company you no longer work for, youre out of luck. Unless youve rolled that money into your current 401 plan, you wont be able to use it.
You could pay taxes and penalties on it. If you dont repay your loan on time, the loan could turn into a distribution, which means you may end up paying taxes and bonus penalties on it.
Youll have to pay it back more quickly if you leave your job. If you change jobs, quit or get fired by your current employer, youll have to repay your outstanding 401 balance sooner than five years. Under the new tax law, 401 borrowers have until the due date of their federal income tax return to repay in such circumstances.
The Issue Of Bankruptcy
Tax penalties are only one problem of using 401K money to repay debt. Another that may be much more problematic has to do with the issue of bankruptcy. Money reports on the details of this common problem. The gist of it is that if you use your 401K to pay your credit card debt, then you havent addressed the underlying issue of whats caused the debt in the first place. As a result, youre likely to get right back into debt. This could lead you to eventually need to file for bankruptcy.
In fact, more and more people are filing for bankruptcy after the age of 65. In other words, people are filing for bankruptcy once they retire. The good news for those people is that 401K money is often protected in bankruptcy. If you have that money in your 401K then you can still use it even if you have to file bankruptcy to discharge credit card debt. However, if you used up your 401K to repay debt but then later still have to file bankruptcy, that money is just gone.
Moving money from your retirement savings to repay credit cards is easy. It can be very tempting. However, its a mistake. Dont do it.
Read More:
K Hardship Withdrawal For Debt Consolidation Good Or Bad Idea
by Lizzy Bale
It is not an uncommon scenario for individuals to find themselves unable to pay their bills. More and more often, people see themselves falling behind on payments, which only increases the amount owed. If you are no longer able to keep up with mounting debt, you are not alone. Thousands of people, everyday, are faced with the same tough decisions you encounter.
Debt consolidation involves using a loan or a lump sum of money to pay off others. Often, debt consolidation allows you to reduce the amount owed, greatly lower the monthly payments, or both. Consolidating debt is arguably the best way to handle past-due bills. This type of credit relief can save you money, time, and stress. However, you may still have the issue of coming up with the funds to pay the lump sum that has been settled for you.
You May Like: How To Transfer 401k Without Penalty
Can I Cash Out My 401k While Still Employed
If your 401k plan is sponsored by your current employer, you can not access this money until you leave employment or suffer a major hardship. If you have an old 401k plan from a previous employer, you can cash this out or take the cash back from it but you may be subject to an early withdrawal penalty.
The Lifestyle Challenges Of Borrowing From Your 401k To Pay Off Debt
According to The Debt Payoff Playbook, retirement contributions should be paused until you tackle your debts. There are several reasons for this sequence. By forcing yourself to change your lifestyle and spending habits, you will be able to tackle your debts quickly.
This is because pain is a motivator.
When you have debt, you acutely feel the pain associated with a debt burden. This keeps you motivated to pay the debt off as fast as you can, to free yourself from this position. After you pay off your debt, it is less likely that you will fall back into your old spending patterns. If you do happen to fall back into debt, you will have a proven strategy to quickly change your course to get back on track.
By pulling from your 401k account to pay off debt, we are assuming that you will contribute back to your 401k loan aggressively. Unfortunately, there is little reward or pain associated with retirement savings. It is delayed gratification that can be easily overlooked.
If you paid your debt off with your retirement, it is easy to justify slowing down retirement to pay for a newer vehicle with a higher payment. It is much easier to justify lowering retirement contributions to purchase consumer goods.
I hope you understand that the debt payoff process is as much psychological as it is mathematical. Its about changing your lifestyle and spending habits that you have held for decades.
Don’t Miss: How To Contribute To 401k Without Employer
Borrowing From Your 401k To Purchase A Home
While it may be tempting to borrow from your 401k plan to purchase a home, understand that you will more than likely be paying a higher interest rate to pay back your 401k loan than you would on a traditional home loan.
Some people borrow from their 401k account for a downpayment on their primary residence. While a 401k loan is a quick way to get a down payment, keep in mind that you will now have a mortgage and 401k loan payment each month that may be difficult to sustain.
Withdrawing From A Roth 401k
Most 401k plans involve pre-tax contributions, but some allow for Roth contributions, meaning those made after taxes already have been paid.
The benefit of making a Roth contribution to your 401k plan is that you already have paid the taxes and, when you withdraw the money, there is no tax on the amount gained as long as you meet these two provisions:
- You withdraw the money at least five years after your first contribution to the Roth account
- You are older than 59 ½ or you became disabled or the money goes to someone who is the beneficiary after your death
You May Like: Can I Use My 401k To Buy Investment Property
It Doesnt Feel Painful To Pull From Your 401k
The fact that our money is so virtual oftentimes means it doesnt feel all that real. Therefore, spending it doesnt always feel as painful as perhaps it should. In particular, it doesnt always hurt to pull money from savings accounts. If its an account that you rarely look at then its even less obvious.
For example, it should be painful to pull money out of your 401K. It costs you penalties when you do. Moreover, you are robbing your future self of money youll need in retirement. And yet, because its so easy to move that money, and because you probably dont even look at your 401K account very often, it doesnt feel as awful as it is.
Can You Pay Off Student Loans With Your 401
Were here to help! First and foremost, SoFi Learn strives to be a beneficial resource to you as you navigate your financial journey.Read moreWe develop content that covers a variety of financial topics. Sometimes, that content may include information about products, features, or services that SoFi does not provide.We aim to break down complicated concepts, loop you in on the latest trends, and keep you up-to-date on the stuff you can use to help get your money right.Read less
If youre one of the 44 million Americans who currently hold a portion of the countrys $1.5 trillion student debt , chances are youve got student loans on the brain. The average student graduates with just over $37,000 in student loan debt.
Paying off that much debt is an impressive feat which takes discipline and commitment. If youre currently living under the heavy weight of your student loans, you may have considered using your 401 for student loans. But should you really cash out your 401 for student loans?
It probably goes without saying that figuring out how youre going to pay off your student loans is overwhelmingand there isnt one definitive solution. And while its certainly tempting to just take the cash from your 401 and pay off a high-interest loan, there are some serious drawbacks to consider before running with that plan.
Recommended Reading: How To Get Money Out Of 401k Without Penalty
One More Con To Be Aware Of For 401k Hardship Withdrawals
If youre thinking of doing this, you likely really do need the money. Ive been there, and I know its really hard, to put it mildly. But theres one more con I want to point out out regarding 401k accounts:
In general, money in qualified 401k accounts is protected from creditors.
This is because of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act , which is a federal law. If you arent sure if your 401k is a qualified account, talk to your plan administrator.
So personally, if I were looking at making a hardship withdrawal from a 401k to pay for past medical care or to prevent eviction or foreclosure, Id want to be sure Id used up my other options first.
I would do things like setting up payment plans, negotiating, and earning extra money that could be used instead.
Once those methods were used up, Id want to think long and hard about whether the withdrawal was actually likely to help over the long run. If it was only a short term fix, and I was likely to end up declaring bankruptcy anyway, I wouldnt do it. I wouldnt want to trade what Id built up for my future for a short-term fix that was unlikely to make a lasting difference.
In other words, I wouldnt want to use up my retirement money and then STILL declare bankruptcy, lose my house, or get evicted because I hadnt yet found a new source of income. For me it would be better to at least have money left in the 401k for the future.
Your situation could be different, but its something to think about.
Tax Penalty For Taking Money Out Of Your Roth 401k Early
Since you paid initial taxes on your Roth 401k contributions, you may take your contributions back out without paying a penalty. In other words, if you invested $25,000 and your investment has grown to $50,000, you may take up to $25,000 out of your Roth without paying an early withdrawal penalty.
In contrast, if you took $30,000 out of your account, you would pay a 10% penalty on the $5,000 because that was an investment gain and more than your $25,000 contribution. However, before you run out and take your contributions out, keep reading to see the devastating impact taking your money out of your investments early can have on your retirement savings.
Read Also: How Do You Find Out About Your 401k
Should I Borrow From My 401k Account To Pay Off Debt
An argument for borrowing from your 401k is to eliminate a large debt with a high-interest rate. Say for instance your $40,000 debt is on a credit card at 16% interest. On the outside, it may seem like a no-brainer to forfeit the 8% a year on your investment instead of paying 16% interest on that debt.
The Size Of Your Mortgage
The point above doesnt mean you shouldnt consider the numbers. The value of your mortgage at retirement could make a huge difference in your payoff plan.
You also need to understand your current tax situation and how taking distributions from your retirement accounts to pay off debt could cause you to change tax brackets and pay more tax than you would otherwise, Poorman says.
If youre retired, any pre-tax money taken out of your 401 is treated as income. So, for example, taking $100K out of your retirement plan to pay off your mortgage could easily bump you up into a higher tax bracket . A balance of $10K probably wont have as large of an impact.
Taking $100K out of your retirement plan to pay off your mortgage could bump you up into a higher tax bracket . A balance of $10K probably wont have as large of an impact.
If you continue to make monthly mortgage payments, the amount of interest you pay may be tax deductible. But that interest needs to be fairly high to make it count. The 2017 Tax Cuts and Job Acts nearly doubled the standard deduction, eliminating itemized deductions, such as mortgage interest, for many Americans.
Protect your mortgage.
If you choose to take your house payments with you in retirement, life insurance provides a form of mortgage protection. With a term insurance policy you can align the length of the term with the length of your mortgage.
Also Check: How To Get Money From 401k Before Retirement
What Other Options Are There If You Need Cash
- If you have a Roth IRA for five years, you can withdraw your original contributions at any age, free of federal taxes and penalties.
- For education expenses, explore scholarships or student loans. You can borrow for school but not for retirement.
- You can borrow against the value of your home with a home equity loan or home equity line of credit.
What Are The Rules And Penalties For Early Ira Withdrawal
Whether you pronounce it eye-ruh or you sound out each letter, an IRA is a great tool to build wealth and make sure you retire with dignity. But the key word here is retire. Dave Ramsey says you shouldnt take money out of your IRA early unless its to avoid bankruptcy or foreclosure. Why? Because using your retirement fund for anything other than retirement can come at a big cost.
Money taken out of an IRA early must be transferred to another retirement account within 60 days to be considered a nontaxable rollover. We repeat: 60 days! Otherwise, the government will take its cut in the form of penalties and taxes. So, if you withdraw money from your 401 because youre changing jobs and want to move it to a new company, make sure you do it within the 60-day period. That way you wont lose any of your savings. After all, its your hard-earned money, and you deserve to hold onto as much of it as possible. Also, keep in mind that nontaxable rollovers can only be done once every 12 months.
As soon as those 60 days are up, the money from the IRA is considered to be cashed out. And the penalties and taxes you have to pay on that money depend on the type of retirement account it came from: 401, traditional IRA or Roth IRA.
Don’t Miss: How To Open A 401k Plan
Rental Property Investor From Gulf Shores Al
You have two options:
1) conduct a withdrawal in which case you will be charged a 10% early withdrawal fee no matter what. You can reduce your tax liability significantly if your portfolio could benefit from a cost segregation analysis. Consult your CPA to understand exactly what this would look like.
2) Use a self directed option to invest in your LLC. Now, you can’t just do this directly but you can form two LLC’s, one that your IRA owns 100% of and another that you are the sole member of and use them together to pay off the debt. Of course, this option depends on if you hold your properties in an LLC…
Tackle Existing Debt In The Way That Suits Your Style
Youll want a plan to eliminate that debt and the accompanying interest and maybe still allows for the occasional spurge at your favorite restaurant. There are two main ways to go about paying off debt the first often referred to as the snowball strategy where you pay your smallest debt first, regardless of interest rate, while making minimum payments on the others. This approach is great for someone who feels inspired by the satisfaction of crossing things off a list.
The second style is called an avalanche, where you make minimum payments on all your debts but use any additional funds to make larger payments on the debt with the highest interest rate. Erasing those first can potentially save more money in the long run.
You May Like: Why Choose A Roth Ira Over A 401k
When Using Your 401 To Pay Off Debt Makes Sense
It might make sense to defy conventional wisdom and dip into your 401 for certain situations.
Employer-sponsored 401 plans form a retirement-planning cornerstone for millions of Americans.
These accounts allow workers to save money for the future through payroll deductions at work and, in many cases, provide an employer match that can significantly bolster retirement nest eggs.
Those participating in 401 plans may contribute up to $19,500 this year, according to the IRS, plus another $6,500 in catch-up savings for workers age 50 and older. Besides saving for the future, employees can lower their current income tax bills by contributing to these tax-deferred accounts.
Financial experts tend to recommend leaving your 401 alone and letting the money grow so youll have it later in life. Current financial needs, however, may tempt you to tap into your retirement account now.
