Weighing The Pros And Cons
When weighing the pros and cons, its important to consider your own personal circumstances, goals and objectives. Are you looking for a personal relationship with an investment advisor, who can manage your IRA investments with an understanding of your situation, needs & objectives, time frames, and risk tolerance? Do you seek to simplify your accounts and have your IRA be part of the overall plan that your financial advisor administers? If having these services is important to you, it may swing your decision toward rolling over. On the other hand, you may decide that asset protection and low fees are more important, and that keeping the 401K where it is makes the most sense.
Do I Have To Pay Taxes When I Roll Over A 401
It depends on whether or not youre changing account types with the rollover. For example, if you move funds from a traditional 401 to a Roth IRAthats called a Roth conversionthen you will owe taxes on the money after the transfer. And that could create a hefty tax bill!
But if youre transferring money from a traditional 401 to a traditional IRA, then you wont owe any taxes on that rollover. The same goes for a rollover from a Roth 401 to a Roth IRA .
If you have questions about whether your 401 rollover counts as a taxable event,get in touch with a tax advisor.
What Happens If You Cash Out Your 401
If you take your 401 money before you reach age 59 ½, you might have to pay taxes at your regular tax rate, on top of a penalty from the IRS, on any money that hasnt been taxed before. You may be able to avoid any penalties for certain life events or purchases, but youll still probably owe taxes on any previously untaxed money.
You May Like: What Is An Individual 401k
How Much Do You Need And At What Risk
A better start to retirement planning begins with an estimate of how much you will need in retirement. You dont have to be accurate down to the penny but should try to estimate your living expenses to the nearest $50,000 or so. Take your current expenses, deducting those that you wont have in retirement like education and retirement savings, and then add in new expenses for things like travel. The Department of Labor Consumer Expenditure survey can help you see how much people spend on average according to their age.
Any retirement calculator will show you the return needed on your investments to meet your future spending needs given things like age, annual savings and current investments. Your next step is to do a reality check on this number.
If you need a return of more than 10% annually on your investments to meet your retirement goals, you may need to rethink your savings rate or your goals. Aiming for such a high annual rate will force you into riskier investments and may cause you to panic-sell when the markets tumble. A return of between 4% and 6% for a blended portfolio of different assets is a more realistic goal.
Your own tolerance for risk will also play a part in your 401k investing plan. Theres nothing wrong with being a conservative investor, preferring stability to the possibility of higher returns. The biggest mistake you could make is chasing returns to the point that market volatility makes you nervous and leads you to commit bad investing behaviors.
Initiate And Complete The 401 Rollover Process
Once you open your new IRA account, its time to begin the rollover process. The simplest way to do this is to get your 401 provider to complete a direct rollover from your 401 account right to your IRA. Each provider will have its own set of requirements for this process, so contact your plan administrator. The IRS will not charge you any taxes in this situation.
The second and less preferable option is the 60-day rollover. In this case, your 401 provider withdraws your 401 balance and gives it to you in the form of a check. Then, as you might expect, you have a 60-day window to get that money deposited in your new tax-deferred account.
However, because this situation involves money passing through your hands, the IRS stipulates that the employer must withhold 20%. That means in order to get the same amount of money into your new account that you had in your 401, youll have to use separate money to make up the difference.
For example, lets assume youre rolling over $50,000 from a 401 to an IRA through a 60-day rollover. Because the check is in your name, your employer withholds $10,000, or 20%, based on IRS rules. If within 60 days, you can find enough cash to replace that $10,000 and deposit the full $50,000 in your new tax-deferred IRA, then youll report that $50,000 as a nontaxable rollover and the $10,000 as taxes paid. Then, come tax time, the IRS will consider that $10,000 to be part of your federal taxes withheld, which means youll get it back.
Also Check: How To Get Money From 401k Early
Are There Tax Implications Of Ira Rollovers
Depending on how you move your money, there might be tax implications. If you move your money into an account with the same tax treatment as your old account, there shouldnt be issues as long as you deposit any checks you receive from your 401 into a tax-advantaged retirement account within 60 days. However, if you move a traditional 401 into a Roth IRA, you could end up with a tax bill. Check with a tax professional to find out how you may be affected.
Should You Roll Over Your 401 Into Another 401
There are some situations that might make an IRA rollover the wrong move for you. Heres what to consider before completing a 401 rollover.
Retirement account protection. In general, 401 accounts offer better protections from creditors than IRAs.
Rule of 55. With a 401, you can actually start withdrawing funds at age 55 penalty-free if you leave your job. You dont have that advantage when you roll your 401 to an IRA, though you can emulate it by taking subsequently equal periodic payments from your IRA
Performance. If you like your current plan, and its performing well, theres no reason to complete a rollover.
You can always choose to roll your old 401 balance into your new employers 401 plan. If you value the simplicity of having everything in one place, you like the features of the plan at your new job or you want to maintain the legal protections of a 401, it may make more sense to roll your old 401 into a new 401.
You May Like: Can You Take Money Out Of 401k
Access More Investment Choices
In a 401 plan, youâre limited to the investment choices picked by your employer, usually a selection of mutual funds. If you roll over your 401 to an IRA, you may be able to expand your investment choices to include a broader range of funds, exchange traded funds or even individual stocks and bonds. Youâll get more control over your portfolio, especially if you use a self-directed IRA, which allows you to invest money into more unorthodox assets like real estate.
Can You Be Required To Roll Over Your 401
Sometimes you have no choice in the matter. You might be required to roll over your 401 if:
⢠You donât meet a minimum balance requirement. For example, if you have less than $5,000 in your 401, your employer can require you to roll your 401 into a different account.
⢠Your old employer changes 401 providers. Depending on your company, your account may not be rolled over and your existing provider may not continue service. If your account is rolled over, the new provider might have requirements you canât meet, or they might not provide the services you want.
Also Check: Can I Keep My 401k After I Leave My Job
Pick An Ira Provider For Your 401 Rollover
When moving your money, you need to figure out which brokerage will provide you with the services, investment offerings and fees you need. If youre a hands-on investor who wants to buy assets beyond stocks, bonds, ETFs or mutual funds, you need to look for a custodian that will allow you to open a self-directed IRA. On the other hand, if youre more hands-off, it might make sense to choose a robo-advisor or a brokerage that offers target date funds.
Get Help With Your 401 Rollover
Having an investment professional in your corner, someone who can help you find the right investments to add to your portfolio and walk you through all the ins and outs of a 401 rollover, makes this process a lot easier.
Dont have an investment professional? No worries! Our SmartVestor program can get you in touch with someone in your area to help you get started.
Also Check: Can I Invest My 401k
How Do You Choose The Best Ira Rollover Promotion
Start by thinking about what youd like to get out of your rollover.
Are you looking for the biggest possible bonus at your balance tier? Would you prefer not to pay account transfer fees? Or do you simply want to find the best custodian for your money?
Once youve decided what you want, evaluate relevant offers carefully. Read each promotions fine print closely. Then, follow up with a careful review of each platforms disclosures, offer restrictions, account fees, and general terms and conditions.
Finally, dont hesitate to act once youre ready. Offer terms and availability are subject to change at any time and at platforms sole discretion, so it could pay to act sooner rather than later.
Youre Our First Priorityevery Time
NerdWallet, Inc. is an independent publisher and comparison service, not an investment advisor. Its articles, interactive tools and other content are provided to you for free, as self-help tools and for informational purposes only. They are not intended to provide investment advice. NerdWallet does not and cannot guarantee the accuracy or applicability of any information in regard to your individual circumstances. Examples are hypothetical, and we encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding specific investment issues. Our estimates are based on past market performance, and past performance is not a guarantee of future performance.
We believe everyone should be able to make financial decisions with confidence. And while our site doesnt feature every company or financial product available on the market, were proud that the guidance we offer, the information we provide and the tools we create are objective, independent, straightforward and free.
So how do we make money? Our partners compensate us. This may influence which products we review and write about , but it in no way affects our recommendations or advice, which are grounded in thousands of hours of research. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable reviews of their products or services.Here is a list of our partners.
Don’t Miss: How To View Your 401k
Rolling Over Your Old 401 To A New Employer
Many companies offer 401 plans, so people often end up having multiple 401s over their years in the workforce. If youd rather keep your funds in a single 401 or dont want to open an IRA, you might have the option of transferring assets from your old 401 to your new one at your current job. If not, youll need to keep an eye on how each is performing individually.
The process for this is as simple as talking to both your current and past plan providers to make sure they will both accept a transfer of assets. While the providers can offer more specific instructions, youll likely use one of the methods above to complete the rollover.
Note that not all plan providers will accept employees past 401 funds as a rollover. This is because they may not be willing to add more assets to the plan, which could overwhelm it.
Why You May Not Want To Roll Over Your 401
Rollovers aren’t for everyone. Consider the following:
You Need Money Access to Your Money Earlier
If you retire early, you can start making withdrawals from your 401 account penalty-free starting at age 55. Under most circumstances, you may not begin making withdrawals from an IRA until age 59 ½.
You Have a Large Number of Assets You Need to Protect
401 assets are protected in the event that you need to declare bankruptcy or you have creditors coming after you. IRA protection status varies by state, so you may not be covered.
If you live in California, Georgia, Maine, Mississippi, or West Virginia, your IRA has the potential to be seized if you are found to be at fault for a costly lawsuit. Even in states that protect IRAs, bankruptcy protection is typically limited to $1.28 million in assets.
You Want to Hold Onto Your Money a Little Longer Before Dipping In
401 accounts and IRAs both require that payouts start to be received no later than when the owner of the account turns 70 ½ years old. However, 401 accounts have a loophole that allows owners to defer these payments until after they actually retire IRAs offer no such loophole.
Don’t Miss: Can I Use My Fidelity 401k To Buy A House
Ira Rollover Vs Transfer
Although both rollovers and transfers allow you to move your retirement savings from one financial institution to another, the process for each is different, and each have different rules.
A 401 rollover occurs when you move retirement funds from an employer-sponsored plan to an IRA this is why it’s also called a Rollover IRA. This option is typically chosen when an employee leaves a job and is no longer contributing to the employer-sponsored retirement plan.
A Transfer is when you move your IRA to another IRA at a different institution. In the case of a transfer, funds or assets are sent between institutions, from the previous custodian or trust company to the new one. This is not only the quickest, but also the best method of moving your IRA to a self-directed IRA.
Choose Your 401 Rollover Destination
Consider whether a traditional IRA or Roth IRA makes the most sense for your 401 rollover.
401 Rollover to Traditional IRA: If you want to maintain the same tax treatment, this can be a good choice, Henderson says. You avoid extra hassle, and you just see the same RMD and tax treatment as you would with your current 401.
401 Rollover to Roth IRA: For those with high incomes, the 401 rollover to a Roth IRA can serve as a backdoor into a Roth tax treatment. But dont forget about the taxes, Henderson says. In addition, remember the five-year rule when it comes to Roth accounts: Even at 59 ½, you cannot take tax-free withdrawals of earnings unless your first contribution to a Roth account was at least five years before. Those close to retirement, therefore, may not benefit from this type of conversion. Talk to a tax professional if youre rolling into an account with different treatment, says Henderson.
Also Check: Can I Transfer My 401k To My Spouse
When To Roll Over Your 401
Tweet This
To roll or not to roll, that is the question at least when youre changing companies or retiring.
Here are some options when you change employers or retire:
The best choice isnt always immediately clear. Here are some considerations to help you with your decision. Which of the following is most important to you?
Simplicity
You may prefer to consolidate your accounts in one place or a limited number of places in order to better stay on top of your money. If your goal is to keep things as straightforward as possible, consider option 2 or option 3 .
Investment options
Sometimes your investment options are limited within your employer’s plan. An IRA rollover account, in contrast, leaves a plethora of investment options open to you.
Consider option 3 if your employers plan lacks investment options that interest you.
Lower fees and expenses
Options for beneficiaries
If this benefit interests you, check with your IRA custodian to make sure your plan allows annual withdrawals for a beneficiary over their life expectancy.
Contact Your Current 401 Provider And New Ira Provider
Ideally, you want a direct rollover, in which your old 401 plan administrator transfers your savings directly to your new IRA account. This helps you avoid accidentally incurring taxes or penalties. However, not every custodian will do a direct rollover.
In many cases, youll end up with a check that you need to pass on to your new account provider, Henderson says. Open your new IRA before starting the rollover so you can tell the old provider how to make out the check.
The goal, Henderson says, is to avoid having to ever put the money into your personal bank account.
You only have 60 days to complete the transaction to avoid it being a taxable event, and its best to have everything set up before getting that check, Henderson says.
Don’t Miss: What Will My 401k Be Worth At Retirement
Option : Keep Your Savings With Your Previous Employers Plan
If your previous employers 401 allows you to maintain your account and you are happy with the plans investment options, you can leave it. This might be the most convenient choice, but you should still evaluate your options. Each year, American workers manage to lose track of billions of dollars in old retirement savings accounts, so you should make sure to track your account regularly, review your investments as part of your overall portfolio and keep the beneficiaries up to date.
Some things to think about if youre considering keeping your money in your previous employers plan:
